Want to see
Air (movie)
Candy Boy (ONA)
Destiny of the Shrine Maiden (TV)
ef: a tale of melodies (TV)
ef: a tale of memories (TV)
Gunslinger Girl (TV)
Higurashi no Naku Koroni Kai (TV)
Kaiji (TV)
Magical Witch Punie-chan (OAV)
Murder Princess (OAV)
NANA (TV)
Nodame Cantabile (TV)
Nodame Cantabile: Paris (TV)
Now and Then, Here and There (TV)
Pet Shop of Horrors (TV)
Shigofumi - Letters from the Departed (TV)
Tohai Densetu Akagi -Yamini Maiorita Tensai- (TV)
True Tears (TV)

Seen some
Bludgeoning Angel Dokuro-chan (TV)
Lucky Star (TV)

Seen all Rating Comment
Ah! My Goddess (TV) Good
Ah! My Goddess: Flights of Fancy (TV) Good
Ai Yori Aoshi (TV) Good
Ai Yori Aoshi ~Enishi~ (TV) Good
Air (TV) Very good
Basilisk (TV) Excellent
Black Lagoon (TV) Very good
Black Lagoon: The Second Barrage (TV)
Chobits (TV) Very good
Clannad (TV)
Clannad After Story (TV)
Cowboy Bebop (TV) Excellent
Death Note (TV) Excellent
Elfen Lied (TV) Masterpiece
Fate/stay night (TV) Very good The ending was kinda ruined by a Dragonball Z villain =P Talk about out of place character designs...
Fruits Basket (TV) Good
Fullmetal Alchemist (TV) Excellent
Fullmetal Alchemist: The Movie - Conqueror of Shamballa Decent Confusing at times, the reasoning for characters actions was often left unexplained. Excessive characters for the sake of fan-pandering. The movie did not need to have a walk-on role by each and every character from the anime.
Genshiken (TV)
Haibane Renmei (TV) Excellent
Hellsing (TV) Decent
Kanon (TV 2/2006) Masterpiece
Karin (TV) Good Less Winner and more manga content would've increased this by a point. Make a point of reading the manga as well.
Kasimasi - Girl Meets Girl (TV) Very good
Kasimasi - Girl Meets Girl (OAV) Very good
Koi Kaze (TV) Masterpiece
Last Exile (TV)
Maria Watches Over Us (TV) Very good
Maria Watches Over Us 3rd Season (OAV) Very good
Maria Watches Over Us Season 2: Printemps (TV) Very good
(The) Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (TV) Masterpiece Broadcast Order. I recommend watching the Broadcast order first and then rewatching the series in Chronological order. It really feels like whole new season the second time through.
Midori Days (TV) Very good
Mushi-Shi (TV) Masterpiece
My-HiME (TV) Very good
Paranoia Agent (TV) Excellent
(Le) Portrait de Petite Cossette (OAV) Decent
Rozen Maiden (TV) Good
Rozen Maiden: Ouvertüre (special) Good
Rozen Maiden: Träumend (TV) Good
Rumbling Hearts (TV) Masterpiece It still gets a masterpiece rating even though the knucklehead picks the wrong girl at the end =| It's not even a contest!
Shuffle! (TV) Very good Would get an "Excellent" except that the appeal of it is limited to people who like these kinds of shows.
(The) Slayers (TV) Good More like... Good and 1/2
Strawberry Panic! (TV)
Welcome to the NHK (TV) Excellent
When They Cry - Higurashi (TV) Masterpiece