A list of anime titles I have seen, rented.

Rented Rating
From Up On Poppy Hill (movie) Masterpiece
Patlabor: The Movie Masterpiece
Redline (movie) Masterpiece
Blade of the Phantom Master (movie) Excellent
Figure 17 (TV) Excellent
(The) Five Star Stories (movie) Excellent
Freedom (OAV) Excellent
Heroic Age (TV) Excellent
KenIchi the Mightiest Disciple (TV) Excellent
Master of Martial Hearts (OAV) Excellent
Mermaid Forest (TV) Excellent
Patlabor 2: The Movie Excellent
Spriggan (movie) Excellent
This Ugly Yet Beautiful World (TV) Excellent
Tokyo Majin (TV) Excellent
Tokyo Majin Gakuen Kenpucho: Tou 2nd Act (TV) Excellent
Wicked City (movie) Excellent
Appleseed Alpha (movie) Very good
Big Wars (movie) Very good
Black Butler (TV) Very good
Desert Punk (TV) Very good
Dirty Pair (OAV) Very good
Dirty Pair OAV 2 Very good
Dirty Pair OAV 3 Very good
Dirty Pair OAV 4 Very good
Dirty Pair OAV 5 Very good
Dojin Work (TV) Very good
El-Hazard: The Wanderers (TV) Very good
Escaflowne: The Movie Very good
Fatal Fury: The Motion Picture Very good
First Squad - The Moment Of Truth (OAV) Very good
Genshiken (TV) Very good
Genshiken 2 (TV) Very good
Ghost Slayers Ayashi (TV) Very good
GUNxSWORD (TV) Very good
Hanaukyo Maid Team: La Verite (TV) Very good
Kino's Journey (TV) Very good
Kurogane Communication (TV) Very good
Mushi-Shi (TV) Very good
Princess Tutu (TV) Very good
(The) Samurai (OAV) Very good
Slayers - The Motion Picture Very good
Toward the Terra (TV) Very good
(The) Tower of Druaga: The Aegis of Uruk (TV) Very good
(The) Tower of Druaga: the Sword of Uruk (TV) Very good
Vampire Hunter D (OAV) Very good
Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust (movie) Very good
Afro Samurai: Resurrection (movie) Good
Amaenaide yo!! Katsu!! (TV) Good
Appleseed (OAV) Good
Argento Soma (TV) Good
Berserk (TV) Good
Black Blood Brothers (TV) Good
Blade of the Immortal (TV) Good
Bounty Dog (OAV) Good
Brain Powered (TV) Good
El Hazard: The Alternative World (TV) Good
Fatal Fury 2: The New Battle (special) Good
Flag (ONA) Good
(The) Galaxy Railways (TV) Good
Gunbuster (OAV) Good
Indian Summer (OAV) Good
Linebarrels of Iron (TV) Good
Madox-01 (OAV) Good
Mass Effect: Paragon Lost (movie) Good
(The) Sacred Blacksmith (TV) Good
Shrine of the Morning Mist (TV) Good
To Love-Ru (TV) Good
Toward the Terra (movie) Good
Urusei Yatsura Special: It's Spring! Take Off! Good
(The) Venus Wars (movie) Good
Afro Samurai (TV) Decent
Angel Links (TV) Decent
Aria the Animation (TV) Decent
Blue Remains (movie) Decent
Cannon Fodder (movie) Decent
Eat-Man '98 (TV) Decent
Eden's Bowy (TV) Decent
Fatal Fury: Legend of the Hungry Wolf (special) Decent
Golgo 13: The Professional (movie) Decent
Jyu-Oh-Sei (TV) Decent
Magnetic Rose (movie) Decent
Memories (movie) Decent
Neo Ranga (TV) Decent
Starship Troopers: Invasion (movie) Decent
Stink Bomb (movie) Decent
Vampire Knight (TV) Decent
Ah My Buddha (TV) So-so
Golgo 13: Queen Bee (OAV) So-so
Ninja Nonsense (TV) So-so
Please Twins! (TV) So-so
Please Twins! (OAV) So-so
Project A-Ko 2: Plot of the Daitokuji Financial Group (OAV) So-so
Project A-ko 3: Cinderella Rhapsody (OAV) So-so
Project A-Ko 4: Final (OAV) So-so
Tales from Earthsea (movie) So-so
Tekken: The Motion Picture (OAV) So-so
Metropolis (movie) Not really good
Sasami: Magical Girls Club (TV) Weak
Jin-Roh - The Wolf Brigade (movie) Bad
Kujibiki Unbalance (OAV) Awful