These are the shows that I enjoy watching the most right now.
The list will change over time as I discover new shows that I like more and as some of these become so familiar that they just are not as much fun any more.
I am not including movies and short OVAs. I might make a movie list later.

My Top 25 Anime Rating Comment
Utawarerumono (TV) Excellent
Tears to Tiara (TV) Excellent 10
Stellvia (TV) Masterpiece 7
Solty Rei (TV) Excellent
Sgt. Frog (TV) Excellent
Scrapped Princess (TV) Excellent
My-Otome (TV) Masterpiece 8
My-HiME (TV) Excellent 9
(The) Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (TV 2009 renewal) Excellent 3 Includes all 28 episodes
Mayo Chiki! (TV) Very good
Maria Watches Over Us (TV) Excellent This includes all of Maria Watches Over Us.
Maid Sama! (TV) Excellent
Koihime Musō (TV) Excellent Includes Shin Koihime Muso and Shin Koihime Muso Otome Tairan
Kiddy Grade (TV) Masterpiece 5
Kamichu! (TV) Masterpiece
K-ON! Season 2 (TV) Masterpiece 1 Includes K-On! season 1
Inuyasha (TV) Excellent 2 Includes The Final Act
Girls und Panzer (TV) Excellent
Figure 17 (TV) Masterpiece 6
Fancy Lala (TV) Masterpiece 4
Daphne in the Brilliant Blue (TV) Excellent
Cat Planet Cuties (TV) Very good
Case Closed (TV) Excellent
Cardcaptor Sakura (TV) Masterpiece
Aria the Animation (TV) Excellent This includes all of the Aria anime.