I tend to rate rather positively, but try to rate fairly.

Read all Rating Comment
Oyasumi Punpun (manga) Masterpiece
Azumanga Daioh (manga) Excellent A genuinely hilarious and well-written manga with great characters. Convincing cuteness and heartwarming moments.
Cardcaptor Sakura (manga) Excellent
Fate/Zero (light novel) Excellent
Gunslinger Girl (manga) Excellent
Hotarubi no Mori e (manga) Excellent
(The) Journey of Shuna (manga) Excellent
Octave (manga) Excellent
Onanie Master Kurosawa (manga) Excellent
Solanin (manga) Excellent
Stargazing Dog (manga) Excellent
Undercurrent (manga) Excellent
Abenobashi: Magical Shopping Arcade (manga) Very good
Alien Nine (manga) Very good
Bamboo Blade (manga) Very good
Baron: The Cat Returns (manga) Very good
Death Note (manga) Very good A deep series with a strong but not entirely consistent sense of originality and intelligence. Excellent characters and technical, high-quality artwork - minus some early inconsistencies and shortcuts.
FLCL (manga) Very good
A Girl Who Runs Through Time (manga) Very good
Girlfriends (manga) Very good
Hanjuku-Joshi (manga) Very good
King of Thorn (manga) Very good A high-tension survival horror with rough art and clichéd but strong characters.
Koikaze (manga) Very good
Metropolis (manga) Very good
Mimi o Sumaseba (manga) Very good
Miyori no Mori (manga) Very good
Mr. Arashi's Amazing Freak Show (manga) Very good
Nymphet (manga by K Watashiya) Very good
Puella Magi Madoka Magica (manga) Very good
Punctures (manga) Very good
Shiroi Heya no Futari (manga) Very good
Toradora! (light novel) Very good
Velveteen & Mandala (manga) Very good
What a wonderful world! (manga) Very good
Angel Cup (manhwa) Good
Claudine...! (manga) Good Impressive in many ways - art, thematic content and detail - but with the fatal flaw of being way too short and rushed. Wonderful characterisation and good story are unable to be expressed, though their presence is remarkable.
Concerto (manga) Good
Cowa! (manga) Good
Dragon Ball (manga) Good Series' heart and quality concentrated on earlier parts of story. Later arcs harm product with repetitiveness, reliance on deus ex machina, and loss of a sense of fun and spirit.
Elfen Lied (manga) Good
(The) Flowers of Evil (manga) Good
Gokujō Drops (manga) Good
Kashimashi ~Girl Meets Girl~ (manga) Good
Kisses, Sighs, and Cherry Blossom Pink (manga) Good
Kyo no Gononi (manga) Good
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha A's (manga) Good
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha Movie 1st The Comics (manga) Good Lacking totally in subtlety, but entertaining and an effective character study of the cast of the film to which it is a companion piece. Excellent artwork and action sequences.
Medaka Box (manga) Good
Neon Genesis Evangelion (manga) Good
Sand Land (manga) Good
Soul Eater (manga) Good
Toki o Kakeru Shōjo: Tokikake (manga) Good
Ultra-Gash Inferno (manga) Good
Alien Nine Emulators (manga) Decent
BAOH (manga) Decent
Blood+ Kowloon Nights (manga) Decent
Cutey Honey (manga) Decent
Devil May Cry 3 (manga) Decent
Figure 17 (manga) Decent
Girls und Panzer: Little Army (manga) Decent
Gorgeous Irene (manga) Decent
K-ON! (manga) Decent A decent series with okay humour and effective characters. Tells too often, rather than showing.
Kuroko no Basuke (manga) Decent
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS (manga) Decent
Mon Seul (manga) Decent
Shōjo Sect (manga) Decent
Strawberry Shake Sweet (manga) Decent
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann: Guren Gakuenhen (manga) Decent
Yu-Gi-Oh! (manga) Decent
K-ON! High School (manga) So-so Wastes considerable potential offered by having the lazy transplanting of the best-written character into new situations with no change. Other than that, much the same as its original incarnation but slightly weaker.
Mai-Chan's Daily Life (manga) So-so It offends more so in its low quality than its subject matter. The incongruity of Mai-chan's happy-go-lucky demeanour and the ludicrously horrific nature of her situation is bizarre and harms reader immersion. That said, Mai-chan's Daily Life is hardy boring.
Miyuki-chan in Wonderland (manga) So-so The various, largely brief situations that comprise the manga play out as nothing more than clichés, lacking humour, impact or erotic appeal.
Rozen Maiden (manga) So-so Good characters and artwork let down by a vague, meandering plot and a lousy ending.
A Transparent Orange in the Lip (manga) So-so
K-ON! College (manga) Not really good Disappointingly inferior to the original manga, its antics feel meaningless and its setting in a college is meaningless. Humour is weaker than the series, characters irritatingly exactly the same.
Sisterism (manga) Not really good
Date A Live (manga) Weak
Iinari! Aibration (manga) Weak
Alice no 100° CC (manga) Bad