Forum - View topicDuplicate persons
|
Goto page Next |
| Author | Message | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dan42 Chief Encyclopedist  Posts: 3042 Location: Montreal |
|
|||||
| This is the place to report duplicate persons. You must indicate:
1) which one is the real name? 2) is this a alias or a mistake? previous duplicate person reports are here Last edited by Dan42 on Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:55 pm; edited 2 times in total |
||||||
|
||||||
Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Please delete:
Hiroaki SATOU (my bad) Hiroaki SATO (correct) Also would someone be able to check the following two, I don't know any Japanese but I have a feeling these may be the same people. Both credited as Character Design for UY Movie #5: Setsuko SHIBUICHI (has more credits, not on the DVD) Setsuko SHIBUNNOICHI (straight off the DVD) Similar time frame, similar tasks: Yoshiyuki ICHIKAWA Yoshiyuki ISHIKAWA I realize they may be different people, but I just wanted to bring them up. |
||||||
|
||||||
| dormcat Encyclopedia Editor  Posts: 9256 Location: New Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC |
|
|||||
Done.
Her name should be Setsuko SHIBUICHI (四分一 節子; しぶいち せつこ), so please remove your submission for Setsuko SHIBUNNOICHI (this last name looks very suspicious in the first sight) as the Character Design of Urusei Yatsura: The Final Chapter (movie), thus I can merge #10818 into #8408 completely. Very rare family name; don't know whether it's a stage name or a real name. Personally I'd like to thank you for mentioning her name. Now I'm really looking forward to her direction work, Momoko (もも子). A story about a handicapped girl and her healthy fraternal twin brother, this could be more a tearjerker than Grave of the Fireflies. 
I really have no idea, because both names are legitimate (eliminating possible misspellings), and minor staff info are hard to find even in kanji, not mention in romaji. However, they *MIGHT* be the same person, for both Crystal Triangle (in which Yoshiyuki ISHIKAWA staffed) and Urusei Yatsura: The Final Chapter (in which Yoshiyuki ICHIKAWA staffed) are produced by Tatsunoko Productions. Looks like the only way is to post the question on their BBS....  |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
Done, I thought it was a bit strange myself... Also is there such a sound as "si"...I can't recall hearing or seeing one. It's always "shi". And if there isn't, can you rename this or do I have to re-submit it? |
||||||
|
||||||
| dormcat Encyclopedia Editor Posts: 9256 Location: New Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC |
|
|||||
It is another romanization method (actually, THE standard method), called Kunrei-shiki (訓令式), taught in Japanese elementary schools. For foreigners like us, modified Hepburn is most commonly used, so し/シ can be spelled as "shi" (Hepburn) or "si" (Kunrei-shiki). Most entries in ANN Encyclopedia use Hepburn, especially modified Hepburn ("wapuro romaji," romanization for word processors) to reduce the use of special letters like ô or ō.
I'm afraid that I don't have the authority to modify entry titles directly. Personally, I'd suggest you resubmit it, which is easiest for it's the only staff position he has. As far as I can tell, all assistants listed in Ai Yori Aoshi manga are romanized with Kunrei-shiki, as in Asahi Katuomaki, Keizou Isikawa, and Mitukage Syoutengai (<- another strange last name. Shopping arcade?!). |
||||||
|
||||||
| abunai Encyclopedia Editor  Posts: 5456 Location: 露命 |
|
|||||
I actively and intensely dislike Kunrei-shiki (or shouldn't that be Kunrei-siki?  ). It is completely counterintuitive (and counterproductive) to have a transliteration system that doesn't transliterate the actual sounds. The sound of し/シ is "shi", not "si". So the transliteration should be "shi", too.
The day I give up the Hepburn system in favour of Kunrei-shiki is the day ...pigs fly, ...the temperature in Hell drops below zero degrees centigrade, ...and they stuff me in my grave. - abunai |
||||||
|
||||||
chris keck Posts: 96 Location: Rhode Island, U.S. |
|
|||||
| FYI,
Here's a nice table that compares the various romaji methods. http://www.wordiq.com/ It would be helpful if the ANN encyclopedia standardized on one type and gave instructions on the submission pages on what to use. Wikipedia has a good example: http://en.wikipedia.org/ Just a suggestion. chris keck |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
Renaming should really be easier, but I guess re-submitting is probably faster... So then it should be... Katsuomaki Ishikawa Mitsukage Shoutengai Satoshi ...right? Tokyopop just has to be different, huh? |
||||||
|
||||||
| chris keck Posts: 96 Location: Rhode Island, U.S. |
|
|||||
| Hello,
dormcat asked me to give more help in vetting these people I reported as probable duplicates. I divided the names into groups. (There are two groups of people in the world, those that divide things into groups and those that don’t.) I couldn’t check the sources given for them, so I just checked the spelling. Please take a look and post a reply if you know anything that can help clear these up. Thank you in advance for all the help you will give me. Different People EmperorBrandon reported that these are indeed two different people. Thank you. Holmes, John #4977 Holmes, Jonathan #29197 Japanese – Romanization These appear to be all romanization variations or typos. I checked them against Japanese names listed in my dictionary (enamdict). I listed the one I think is correct first. Please post a response if you know differently. Hashimoto, Kouichi #7628 Hashimoto, Kohichi #21402 Hamauzu, Taeko #30627 Hamautsu, Taeko #25492 Hamauzu is listed. Hatano, Yoshifumi #9469 Hatano, Yoshihumi #13440 Hattori, Katsuhisa #9983 Hattori, Katuhisa #4652 Hirata, Shuichi #377 Hirata, Syuichi #30671 Hori, Katsunosuke #6599 Hori, Katusnosuke #20432 Typo Hata, Shoji #10427 Hata, Syouji #10469 Hashimoto, Takashi #9522 Hashimoto, Takasi #15559 Honda, Yuu #31598 Honda, Yuh #15907 Hiromoto, Shinichi #14235 Hiromoto, Sin-Ichi #29678 Hirose, Izumi #30328 Hirose, Idumi #31628 The kana spelling is いづみ Higashi, Junichi #89 Higashi, Jyunichi #16455 Hisamura, Katsu #4194 Hisamura, Kazu #14523 Both are legitimate names. Hiraishi, Motoko #16675 Hiraishi, Motuko #8046 Typo Hirayama, Madoka #10619 Hirayama, Madaoka #10622 Japanese – Alternate Spellings Hiiragi, Mifuyu #1071 Hiigari, Mifuyu #17850 Hiigari isn’t listed. Hirano, Fumi #1662 Hirano, Fumie #25715 Both are legitimate names. Hironaka, Masashi #5118 Hironaka, Wasashi #8367 Plus maybe: Hironaku, Masashi #9944 and Hironobu, Masashi #11653 Wasashi and Hironaku aren’t in the dictionary. Hisamatsu, Yasuo #17597 Hisamitsu, Yasuo #5640 Both are legitimate names. Hiyama, Nobuyuki #1497 Hiyama, Noboyuki #10942 Nobuyuki is in the dictionary, Noboyuki is not. Hosono, Masaya #25097 Hosono, Masayo #18266 Both are legitimate names. Hozumi, Takanobu #12302 Hozumi, Takanofu #25830 My dictionary has 40 kanji writings of takanobu, none of takanofu. Haijima, Naohira #22947 Haijima, Naohisa #3716 Both are legitimate names. Hanai, Masaaki #19182 Hanai, Massaki #16289 Both are legitimate names. Handa, Terou #31341 Handa, Teruo #4718 Both are legitimate names. Harada, Yoshio #18712 Harada, Yoshirou #18600 Both are legitimate names. Haseba, Atsushi #13623 Hasebe, Atsushi #21669 Both are legitimate names. Hasegawa, Katsuo #9805 Hasegawa, Kazuo #23365 Both are legitimate names. Hasegawa, Naoko #3400 Hasegawa, Nahoko #29704 Nahoko is not listed. Hatanaka, Toshi #26629 Hatanaka, Toshio #6709 Both are legitimate names. Hayase, Hiroyuki #22262 Hayase, Horoyuki #17995 Horoyuki is not listed. Hidaka, Masamitsu #8124 Hidaka, Masemitsu #8 Masemitsu is not listed. Higure, Yuichi #23617 Higure, Yuuichi #25320 Both are legitimate names. Hirai, Hisaishi #18159 Hirai, Hisashi #8024 Both are legitimate names. Hirata, Kaoru #5873 Hirata, Kahoru #24216 Both are legitimate names. Hishinuma, Toshihito #10172 Hishinuma, Yoshihito #23 Both are legitimate names. Other Asian Languages Is anyone familiar enough with Asian languages to determine if these are indeed duplicates and if so which is correct? Hye-Sook, Kwon #29785 Hyn Soon, Kwon #24310 Hyun-Joo, Lee #29784 Hyun-Woo, Lee #29790 Other Language – Misspelling Hook, Patrick #12686 Hook, Partick #15981 Typo, unless there really is someone named Partick. Other Language – Long/Short and Middle Names These are names with long and short forms, names with and without middle names or initials. I don’t know what the ANN policy in names so I put the form with the most information first. Again, if anyone knows for sure that any are two different people please pipe-up. Hajj, Edward #4673 Hajj, Ed #4677 Harper, Jay #23464 Harper, J.W. #9600 Holt, Lance J. #27573 Holt, Lance #31018 Haswell, Peter R. #3987 Haswell, Peter #20772 Hayes, Kent Harrison #20972 Hayes, Kent #3964 Hewitt, Cindy Davis #7714 Hewitt, Cindy #18043 Hewitt, Donald H. #7715 Hewitt, Donald #18044 Hudnall, James D. #13946 Hudnall, James #25267 Hirayama, Beni Axia #27645 Hirayama, Beni #6834 Henderson, A.J. #7042 Henderson, A. J. #15007 Plus maybe: Henderson, Adam #11604 Other Language – Alternate Spellings These names have similar pronunciations but different spellings. Can anyone say which is correct? Hamilton, Edmund #6366 Hamilton, Edmond #20064 Hamilton, Jocelyn #4152 Hamilton, Jacelyn #18414 Hagopian, Dean #7041 Hagopien, Dean #9174 Note: If spelled the same as my friend’s name, Hagopian is correct. Haddock, Gary G. #6375 Haddock, Gary #15706 Haddock, Gray G. #355 Haddock, Gray #6976 Haddock, G. #17959 Does anyone know if Gary and Gray are the same person? Halstead, Dana #4686 Halsted, Dana #7396 Harden, Billy F. #9575 Hardin, Billy #16515 Hollingshead, Megan #1435 Holligshead, Megan #27509 Looks like a typo. Hughes, Deniz #7949 Hughes, Beniz #12264 Hurtz, Bill #24875 Hurtzs, William #29055 Again, thanks for helping. chris keck |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Another one:
Masaki SAKAMOTO (On DVD credits for UY M#4) Masanori SAKAMOTO (Not on DVD, but in Masaki's spot) Last edited by Samurai CDZ on Fri Nov 12, 2004 1:12 am; edited 1 time in total |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Tsugio OZAWA (correct)
Tugio OZAWA |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Please delete/merge:
Asahi KATUOMAKI #32419 in favor of: Asahi KATSUOMAKI #32603 Keizou ISIKAWA #32424 in favor of: Keizou ISHIKAWA #32604 who may also be listed as: Keizou ICHIKAWA #10464 Mitukage SYOUTENGAI #32427 in favor of: Mitsukage SHOUTENGAI #32605 Satosi KITUYAMA #32429 in favor of: Satoshi KITSUYAMA #32606 |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Kumiko TAKAHAHI (typo)
Kumiko TAKAHASHI (correct) |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Please merge:
Jonathon GUGGENHELM #32433 (typo) Jonathan GUGGENHEIM #32646 (correct) |
||||||
|
||||||
| Samurai CDZ Posts: 776 Location: Manhattan, KS |
|
|||||
| Katsuhisa YARNADA #4254 (typo)
Katsuhisa YAMADA #4306 (correct) CW MADISON #32679 (Shortened on DVD) Christopher-Wilem MADISON #32685 (Full name) |
||||||
|
||||||
 |
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum |
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
Robert's Anime Corner Store
Visit AniplexUSA.com
Rightstuf
