Forum - View topic
REVIEW: Puella Magi Madoka Magica Vol. 2 Blu-Ray

@Fencedude: I can see some similarities in the thread (only like 30% or so) between Volume 1 and Volume 2 reviews (deja vu).

lol I remembered the part where gg made it look like that Sayaka was a yuri fangirl Anime hyper

(It's like two people in love or something)

Watch out, KentaMaeba is here. You guys better be very have or you might get destroyed, too.

I know what you all need, people.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD-_oLjmCGY

Sigh. Don't even know where to begin! Not that it matters, since, as I mentioned before, it's me vs everyone. For one, I often glance at these talkback threads, and there's ALWAYS negative feedback for anything, at least in all the ones I see (unless it only makes it to 3 or 4 posts). Like I said before, I don't think it's fair to other shows to have NOBODY saying anything bad about it in here. There was that one guy I quoted in my first post, and even he was still being pretty positive. He basically said the show is a C+ at worst; that's not exactly terrible.

Also, you people keep saying that I'm 'presenting my opinion as fact' and that's why my arguments are invalid. At the same time, you also keep saying I 'hated Madoka', which I already said I didn't. It was mostly forgettable, but it's not as though I didn't get a little enjoyment out of seeing the story progress. Then it ended, and I was done. That was that.

Fencedude, I feel like your 'neither here nor there' comment about Infinite Stratos is very much here, and there. I've never seen it, so I can't say anything about it, but clearly its popularity annoys you. Now, imagine if it had Madoka's popularity. Madoka's glowing reviews. Madoka's supposed depth. You can't honestly tell me that wouldn't get to you in any way. Oh, and you didn't refute what I said about the characters at all...

And no, I'm not saying side characters shouldn't exist. I'm saying they DON'T exist in this show. The mother was never developed in any way. Even compared to the main cast, she's devoid of a personality. She's the mother. That's all you get, and you're supposed to see her as a sympathetic figure just based on that? I don't buy it. The brother is even worse, but I don't remember the ending well enough to get into what they did with him. And ok, gg's subs were bad. I don't really feel like your translation changes the context very much. In fact, it takes away that one possible effective use the line could've had that I alluded to earlier (which is irrelevant I guess, since it wasn't delivered in such a way).

The limited edition collections are just amazing; they are easily worth the extra money in my opinion. I would recommend that anybody who is even considering getting them to do so (as long as you aren't barely scraping by each month). Worth every penny.

Did you miss the last episode or something.

Whatever, you're really bad at this. I keep getting accosted for supposedly doing things that you're doing constantly. It's a 'cold hard fact' that the characters are deep and you don't need to explain it? See, this is the part where you admit that you don't know why you like the characters. It's ok. You can like them. What bugs me is you pretending so hard that there's some greater meaning behind everything, and everyone is backing you up; lol's abound, because they don't actually have anything to say.

It's so obvious, that telling me would be an insult to my intelligence! Are we really going to keep doing this? Everyone else in the thread agrees with you. Considering you have nothing to say, can't you just let that be enough?

	Anime News Network Forum Index -> Site-related -> Talkback	All times are GMT - 5 Hours Goto page Previous Next
Page 7 of 25

Forum - View topicREVIEW: Puella Magi Madoka Magica Vol. 2 Blu-Ray

Forum - View topic
REVIEW: Puella Magi Madoka Magica Vol. 2 Blu-Ray