Review

by Carl Kimlinger, Jan 18th 2011

Naruto

DVD - Season 4 Box Set 1 [Uncut]

Synopsis:
Naruto DVD Season 4 Box Set 1
No matter how badly you might want to train yourself or hunt for your missing friend, if you're a ninja, your ninja duties still need fulfilling. As often as not for Naruto that means washing the nostrils of Hidden Leaf's Hokage statues or babysitting bratty rich kids. But occasionally his missions do carry him past the borders of his town, and when they do bad things are usually afoot. In the Land of Birds the bad things involve a phantom warrior, a prince who isn't what he seems, and, of course, a usurping grand vizier. The ugliness in Land of Sea involves the remnants of one of Orochimaru's nastier human experiments and a leftover henchman with a pet fish-girl. In the Land of Stars, the theft of a meteorite with mysterious powers reveals foul secrets that seriously muck up a delicate mission. Bodyguarding some merchants in the Land of Greens gets Naruto involved with a coldhearted princess being pursued by a trio of nasty ninja. It's enough to make a pint-sized shinobi despair. Luckily between missions he can relax with such time-honored pastimes as ramen battles and yeti husbandry.
Review:

Filler stories are what series do to rest up in between important plot points. They aren't intended to continue uninterrupted like this. When they do, the same thing happens that happens whenever anything lazes nonstop: Naruto gets flabby.

The flab most readily apparent is in the show's visuals. How well the filler fights are set up can be variable, but their execution isn't. They're shoddy excuses for action every one, diabolical attempts to redefine animated laziness. Animation is repeated with insulting obviousness, detail levels head over the cliff and into the ground and character designs go off model while backgrounds, already sadly undistinguished, disappear with impunity. Movement from background to foreground is so hideously cheap that laughable perspective problems proliferate like sloppily-drawn rabbits. Earlier in the filler run it was becoming clear that the animators' hearts were no longer in their work. Now they don't even care whether it's obvious that they don't care. It's a double layer of we-don't-give-a-sh*t, and it smothers the non-active animation as well. While designs for canon characters are decent, if unevenly rendered and occasionally stripped of their relevant details, the new designs display so little investment that they might as well be automatons: bland, inexpressive, and completely interchangeable. Framing, staging, facial expression—all equally uninspired. The series has been feeding on processed food so long that it can't remember what red-blooded entertainment looks like, much less how to cook it up.

And that forgetfulness extends to far more than just Studio Pierrot's animation. These are 28 very long episodes, providing ample opportunity to observe the cycling and recycling of signature behaviors, signature ninja moves, and signature dialogue. Nothing is ever invented or changed, merely repeated ad nauseum. Nar>uto goofs off and eats ramen. Sakura wigs out and hits Nar>uto. Shino shoots bugs and says little. Hinata looks adorable and pines shyly after Nar>uto. One could go on forever about Nar>uto's "I'll never forgive you" tantrums and the cheap potshots at Rock Lee's training fetish, and it often seems like the series does exactly that. It's constant déjà vu, particularly given that the filler arcs each use the exact same plot: Nar>uto and a selection of Konoha ninjas go on a mission to another nation, encounter a young person of some variety, run afoul of evil, usually perpetrated by an authority figure, and bash the evil while teaching the young person about friends and dreams and loyalty and all that good stuff. It gets quite tiring after a time.

All of the repetition and throwaway screenwriting may be killing their spirits, but the animators haven't suffered through it without refining their filler storytelling. And this epic box o' filler provides ample opportunity to observe that as well. The set encompasses a great many fairly lengthy arcs, and tellingly not one approaches earlier disasters (Curry of Life anyone?) in irredeemable stupidity. Some of the one-offs do, and at least one—in which Nar>uto teaches a snot-nosed rich kid that money can't buy everything—handily surpasses them. But the longer arcs not only don't completely fail, they occasionally do something right. Usually one thing, but hey, that's better than nothing. In the Land of Sea arc it's the handy use they make of the long, dark shadow cast by Orochimaru. In the Land of Stars arc it's the creation of a despicable, eminently pummel-able villain. The Land of Greens arc conjures up an array of interesting enemy ninjutsu, and a series of correspondingly interesting countermeasures. The Land of Birds...let's call it the exception that proves the rule. By exploiting their individual strengths these arcs can sometimes tap into the series' deep reservoir of junk-food entertainment, and sometimes even manage a semblance of tension and emotional weight. Of course, possessed as they are of an awe-inspiring dearth of skill and subtlety, the arcs inevitably dissolve into puddles of either cheese or syrup. Again though, that's better than nothing.

This mega-set is the combination of two previous sets, namely numbers 13 and 14. So: same old extras (storyboard comparisons and production art mainly), same old content, same old menus, and same old dub. New space-saving packaging though. The dub sounds slack, but no one can really blame the cast or the crew for that. After all, even the once-cool music has lost heart, throwing out its signature compositions with the enthusiasm of a terminal patient. Occasionally the cast and the script do rise above the content, particularly during the overtly goony episodes when they are given a chance play it loose. The dumb ditty sung during the "Laughing Shino" episode is far superior in English, and some of the little zingers Maile Flanagan slips in are quite fun. The supporting cast also makes the best of their increased screen time, but they might as well be plugging the dyke with their fingers. Which is exactly what their Japanese counterparts were doing, so they're actually quite faithful that way.

"Over 11 hours of NARUTO action!" trumpets the cover. Anyone who sits through this entire set may well argue with the "action" part of that statement—the limp, dead things that it tries to pawn off as ninja fights are hardly worthy of the word—but no one will argue with its temporal boast. Watching as each disc disgorges its cargo of monotonous idiocy, you'll feel every one of those long, long eleven hours.

Grade:
Production Info:
Overall (dub) : C
Overall (sub) : C
Story : C
Animation : C-
Art : C+
Music : C+

+ Marginally improved filler arcs; occasionally amusing.
What was tedious in fourteen-episode box-sets is intolerable in a 28-episode one.

Director:Hayato Date
Script:
Kou Hei Mushi
Yuka Miyata
Satoru Nishizono
Katsuyuki Sumisawa
Yasuyuki Suzuki
Junki Takegami
Akatsuki Yamatoya
Michiko Yokote
Shin Yoshida
Storyboard:
Tetsuro Amino
Hayato Date
Takafumi Hayashi
Yuki Hayashi
Tsubute Hyakuno
Hayauma Ippaku
Satoru Iriyoshi
Takaaki Ishiyama
Mashu Itō
Kei Jūmonji
Shigenori Kageyama
Hiroki Kawashima
Hiroshi Kimura
Yuki Kinoshita
Kazumi Kobayashi
Junya Koshiba
Rion Kujo
Masaaki Kumagai
Yasuaki Kurotsu
Koji Masunari
Hitoyuki Matsui
Tsuyoshi Matsumoto
Tokuyuki Matsutake
Yasuhiro Minami
Yuichiro Miyake
Masahiko Murata
Noriyoshi Nakamura
Atsushi Nigorikawa
Toshiya Niidome
Mitsutaka Noshitani
Seiji Okuda
Takeyuki Sadohara
Mamoru Sasaki
Shinji Satoh
Toshiyuki Shimazu
Hirofumi Suzuki
Tetsuji Takayanagi
Chiyuki Tanaka
Toshiyuki Tsuru
Hidehito Ueda
Yasunori Urata
Atsushi Wakabayashi
Yuu Yamashita
Ryo Yasumura
Episode Director:
Hayato Date
Kiyomu Fukuda
Hayato Goda
Yuki Hayashi
Yasuyuki Honda
Masayuki Iimura
Mashu Itō
Shigenori Kageyama
Keiichiro Kawaguchi
Hiroshi Kimura
Yuki Kinoshita
Rion Kujo
Masaaki Kumagai
Tsuyoshi Matsumoto
Kyosuke Mikuriya
Shuuji Miyahara
Masahiko Murata
Atsushi Nigorikawa
Toshiya Niidome
Mitsutaka Noshitani
Yukio Okazaki
Takeyuki Sadohara
Shinji Satoh
Akira Shimizu
Yoshihiro Sugai
Chiyuki Tanaka
Toshiyuki Tsuru
Yasunori Urata
Atsushi Wakabayashi
Kazuyoshi Yokota
Unit Director:
Rion Kujo
Tokuyuki Matsutake
Hirofumi Suzuki
Toshiyuki Tsuru
Yuu Yamashita
Music:
Musashi Project
Toshio Masuda
Original Manga:Masashi Kishimoto
Character Design:
Tetsuya Nishio
Hirofumi Suzuki
Art Director:Shigenori Takada
Art:
Tomoyuki Shimizu
Shinji Sugiyama
Kazuhiko Suzuki
Shigenori Takada
Michiko Taniguchi
Animation Director:
Naoki Aisaka
Mariko Aoki
Atsushi Aono
Seiko Asai
Yukiko Ban
Choi Jong Gi
Hideki Hashimoto
Kumiko Horikoshi
Masaru Hyodo
Yasuhiko Kanezuka
Kazuhisa Kosuga
Akira Matsushima
Tokuyuki Matsutake
Minoru Morita
Yuji Moriyama
Kenichiro Ogata
Yukimaro Ohtsubo
Hidehiko Okano
Hiromi Okazaki
Takako Onishi
Takeshi Ozaka
Kazuya Saitoh
Chikara Sakurai
Gorou Sessha
Haruo Sotozaki
Hirofumi Suzuki
Shinichi Suzuki
Marie Tagashira
Chiyuki Tanaka
Akihiro Tsuda
Takenori Tsukuma
Zenjirou Ukulele
Atsushi Wakabayashi
Masafumi Yamamoto
Hideyuki Yoshida
Sound Director:Yasunori Ebina
Director of Photography:Atsuho Matsumoto
Producer:
Tomoko Gushima
Hiroshi Hagino
Ken Hagino
Noriko Kobayashi

Full encyclopedia details about
Naruto (TV)

Release information about
Naruto - Season 4 Box Set 1 [Uncut] (DVD)

discuss this in the forum (6 posts) |
bookmark/share with:

Add this anime to

Add this DVD to
Around The Web