Will not finish Rating Comment
Ayakashi - Samurai Horror Tales (TV) Excellent I would've given this a masterpiece, but I've heard the other two arcs are not very good at all, so this rating is for the Bakeneko arc only (minus one point for not being only Bakeneko). The Bakeneko arc (eps. 9-11) is a fabulous piece of art, with an excellent storyline.
Rurouni Kenshin (TV) Excellent All the canon episodes were excellent, especially the entire Kyoto Arc. Everyone I know has said the third season is a complete waste of time and total filler, so I just ended while it was good, and bought all the manga instead. I rated this an Excellent for the canon episodes, although it really should be a Masterpiece, if it wasn't for all the filler.
Bleach (TV) Very good Was extremely good all the way through the Soul Society Arc, and then the filler killed it. Even when they returned to canon episodes, they kept interspersing filler until I got fed up and quit. Plus the animation quality dropped so much, it completely irritated me and made watching it a chore, not a pleasure. I'll just stick with the manga.
Naruto (TV) Very good Like Bleach, Naruto was a lot of fun, up until the final battle between Naruto and Sasuke. Then like 100 eps of crappy filler followed. When Shippuuden finally started up, they dragged out the episodes SO much, and dropped the art quality correspondingly (except for Sakura's big fight; that was pretty cool), I gave up in frustration. I mean, really, how long were Kakashi and Naruto in that stupid tree canyon?
Ranma ½ (TV) Very good I really liked this at first (it was the first anime I saw and recognized as anime), but when I found out it went for over a hundred episodes, I stopped. Especially since it doesn't really progress anywhere. Ranma and Akane never get together, and she never figures out Ryoga is P-chan. What's the point?
Naruto Shippūden (TV) Good See Naruto.
xxxHOLiC (TV) Good Extremely beautiful to watch, but with no story arc, it didn't hold my interest.
Major (TV) Decent
Nabari no Ou (TV) Decent
Saber Rider and the Star Sheriffs (TV) Decent Too silly to ever watch seriously, but I gave it a decent for nostalgia. I saw this when I was pretty young, and this is probably the first anime I ever saw, without knowing what anime was. I thought it was super cool. I recently saw a clip on youtube, and laughed my self silly.
Tsubasa: RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE (TV) Decent Like the Inuyasha necklace, I threw up my hands when the feathers exploded. Very pretty to watch, but too bothersome to follow.
Basquash! (TV) So-so Started off strong, but degenerated into fanservice spectacle and I gave up. Really good ending song though.
Blast of Tempest (TV) So-so
Earl and Fairy (TV) So-so
From the New World (TV) So-so
Gakuen Alice (TV) So-so
Gilgamesh (TV) So-so This actually didn't look so bad, but then I lost interest in the story somewhere, and there's too much more interesting anime out there for me to bother.
Inuyasha (TV) So-so Too effing long to get involved in. The world looks kinda cool, but as soon as I saw that necklace shatter into five billion pieces I gave up.
ItaKiss (TV) So-so The main guy is such an arrogant prick, I can't tolerate the main girl being all love-love about him. She's a spineless airhead. Apparently he does get better later on, but I don't even want to bother with this.
Kasimasi - Girl Meets Girl (OAV) So-so I don't think yuri is my thing. Concept was too weird, with the aliens and such.
Kyo kara Maoh! (TV) So-so
A Little Snow Fairy Sugar (TV) So-so Too cutesy and kiddish.
Macross Frontier (TV) So-so Potentially a really really good looking series, until all the flagrant fanservice with Sheryl drove me away. Really a bummer, because aside from the annoying fanservice, the anime looked quite interesting.
(The) Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (TV) So-so
Nighthead Genesis (TV) So-so Younger brother was too whiny, and animation wasn't all that. Got terrible reviews from people who did see it, so I didn't bother.
Project A-Ko (movie) So-so Too many boobs.
Vampire Knight (TV) So-so A very pretty anime, full of bishies, but the angst and emoness drove me crazy.
Welcome to the NHK (TV) So-so Too much innuendo.
Excel Saga (TV) Not really good Too weird.
Gravitation (TV) Not really good The blond guy is a cold bitch, and the pink guy's a big baby. Boring as hell.
Kimagure Orange Road (TV) Not really good Didn't look interesting, and the animation style is too dated for my tastes. I can make exceptions, like for Here is Greenwood, but the storyline just didn't hook me.
Loveless (TV) Not really good I hate loli/shouta anime.
Otaku no Video (OAV) Not really good ... not my thing, I guess.
Saiyuki (TV) Not really good Crappy animation lost my interest.
Sword Art Online (TV) Not really good
Accel World (TV) Weak
Bakumatsu Gijinden Roman (TV) Weak
Code:Breaker (TV) Weak
Humanity Has Declined (TV) Weak
Level-C (OAV) Weak Yech. Too porny. And the guys weren't even good looking.
Pretty Cure (TV) Weak Too cutesy girly.
Strawberry Eggs (TV) Weak Too much fanservice.
Amnesia (TV) Bad
D4 Princess (TV) Bad Saw part of this in an anime club, and it was just stupid to even bother finishing.
Happy Lesson (TV) Bad Hate harem anime.
My Sexual Harassment (OAV) Bad WAY WAY past my comfort zone!
Sakura Diaries (OAV) Bad Watched part of this on a whim, but it's too sexual.
Knight Hunters (TV) Awful Bishies and my favorite VA couldn't even overcome the crappy animation and completely terrible storyline.
Kokoro Library (TV) Awful Too girly and the sisters are weird.
07-Ghost (TV)
Fate/stay night (TV)
GUNxSWORD (TV) First episode did not grab me. Van looks like a plain ripoff of Spike Spiegel, which didn't help. Did not like character designs, except for Van's. Bored.
Magikano (TV) Pathetic fanservice harem anime. Not even funny.
Night Raid 1931 (TV)
Pokémon (TV) Too old for Pokemon, although I wouldn't mind giving it a chance, subbed.
Rainbow - Nisha Rokubō no Shichinin (TV)
Saki (TV) The mahjong parts were great. The unnecessary over the top fanservice was not. Ruined a potentially interesting anime.