Forum - View topicShelf Life - Me, Myself, and Yourself
Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3, 4 Note: this is the discussion thread for this article |
Author | Message | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Echo_City
Posts: 1236 |
|
|||||||
Not all HD is equal, sadly. Normally I can begrudgingly accept the Crunchy quality but when FTNW started "sending signals" that it was a visual series I got leery and when I saw heavy banding-an unintended artifact-in an aura-esque radiance from a character in Episode One I knew that I wouldn't properly enjoy the show on CR as I'd be constantly irked by the quality. The path that a HD Purist is fated to walk is not an easy one
If only there were Sentai releases in my local best buys.
I do like this sort of thing, a morally ambiguous story, so this gets my hope up for the show. |
||||||||
yuna49
Posts: 3804 |
|
|||||||
No, it's deeper than that. Rather than telling us what you've heard, maybe you should watch the show first. That's basically an example of the complaint I expressed before about the nature of most anime discussions. Lots of comments based on rumors or things people "heard" about a show. In general I don't express opinions about shows I have not seen. I wish others would do the same. |
||||||||
fireaxe
Posts: 503 Location: Trois-Rivieres, Canada |
|
|||||||
|
||||||||
Raneth
Posts: 271 |
|
|||||||
I'm late (work sucks) and others have already explained it for me, but basically the dystopian society is not presented as an evil enterprise that the MC must defeat. spoiler[As the show goes on, the MC becomes part of the society and for the most part upholds its ideals, despite some horrors she's witnessed.]
Yes, there is a reason. spoiler[In a fairly lengthy info-dump early on, it's revealed that humanity's genetic makeup has been melded with that of bonobos (which are primates known for their bisexual activities), resulting in a society of bisexuality where tension and aggression are released through sexual contact, regardless of the sex of the individuals.] Despite this, and despite the manga, the sexuality aspect of the world is not elaborated upon for most of the show. There is one episode that establishes this as part of the world after the info dump, and from then on other events take precedence. |
||||||||
Maidenoftheredhand
Posts: 2632 |
|
|||||||
I usually agree with Bamboo but I guess you can agree all the time and well From the New World was definitely worthy of my shelf.
|
||||||||
HitokiriShadow
Posts: 6251 |
|
|||||||
Then feel free to correct it. I saw part of it, I made it clear that I saw only part of it earlier in the thread and made it clear here that I wasn't basing it on what I saw myself. I generally don't talk about shows unless I feel I saw enough to get a grasp on the issues being discussed. There is certainly an issue with people acting like authorities on things they didn't watch (at all or in their entirety) is an issue, but it's equally silly to suggest that people shouldn't express an opinion or otherwise talk about something that they only partially saw. If they have a particular stake in the argument, there words obviously just shouldn't carry as much weight. |
||||||||
yuna49
Posts: 3804 |
|
|||||||
Sorry, but your posting referred to what you had heard, not what you had seen. If your comments were based on the parts of the show that you watched, then say so. There was no evidence that your comments in the posting to which I replied were based on actual viewing of Shin Sekai Yori. The relevant material appeared in episode four. I don't think it was unreasonable of me to read your comments as indicating you had watched little or nothing of this show.
Certainly there was nothing in the show to suggest the relationships depicted had anything to do with the "Class-S" genre of story where girls crush on other girls, often in a non-sexual way. In fact there are both male and female homosexual relationships depicted in Shin Sekai Yori and heterosexual ones spoiler[like Shun and Saki in the boat and the aborted encounter between Saki and Satoru in the tree] suggested as well. You can't expect everyone to review an entire thread before commenting on a particular posting. I do my best to try and recall prior postings before commenting in a thread, but everyone's memories are fallible. |
||||||||
jl07045
Posts: 1527 Location: Riga, Latvia |
|
|||||||
It is besides the point, because Shin Sekai Yori does not intend to moralize about our current issues. What we find progressive here and now is probably not even relevant in that society, which has different issues, different values, different behavioural models and even people with different genetic makeup. So even if they had something comparable to Class-S situation, complaining about it from our own standpoint would be pointless. |
||||||||
danilo07
Posts: 1580 |
|
|||||||
So if there are two girls or guys kissing,we immediately classify that situation as fanservice?That sounds really stupid to me.It is quite obvious that homosexual pairings in Shin Sekai Yori weren't created to satisfy either otaku or fujioshi. Does "Blue Is the Warmest Colour" have a lot of fanservice moments?Gee that thing has sex scenes with lesbians,what are possible intent could have the creators had besides getting people to jack off to those scenes.
|
||||||||
jree78
Posts: 123 |
|
|||||||
There was a specific reasons for the homosexual relationships in the show: spoiler[One it was a way for adolescents to relieve their stress it seems they were engineered to be only homosexual during their teenage years by design. Two the other reason they were designed that way is to eliminate the chance of reproduction among teenagers. Third all the teenagers have some kind of homosexual relationships when they are younger. Fourth when they are past a certain age they develop heterosexual relationships, otherwise their society would die off. Finally they do this because they are trying to prevent one of the students to be a "Sandy Hook killer" (totally crazy psychopath) using psychokinesis. This is a small aspect of what they do to prevent a kid from going nuts.]
|
||||||||
acetatsujin
Posts: 208 |
|
|||||||
Myself; Yourself is one of the very, very best anime out there. Excellent in many ways and no miracles involved. I love this type of series. I've watched it many times and I hold it very dear to me.
|
||||||||
eyeresist
Posts: 995 Location: a 320x240 resolution igloo (Sydney) |
|
|||||||
Here I am, late to the party again. All I know about "From the New World" is the title is from Dvorak's 9th symphony, but from what people are saying it suffers a problem common to a lot of anime - lack of relatable characters.
I've been previewing a lot of series lately, and this does seem to be the main thing that makes me cross off most titles, including Myself Yourself (saw 1st ep). The set-up was obviously supposed to be intriguing, but the characters weren't distinctive or interesting, just walking plot points. Also, as Bamboo points out, the whole thing seems really plodding and prosaic despite the supposed dramatic content. The Yamato movie (whole thing is on yt) has the problem of a lot of Japanese genre movies, which is the director seems to have no real sense of drama. I get the feeling they get promoted to the position for reasons of precedence rather than flair, and generally show as much real story-telling as if they were just shooting a gameshow. I understand getting directing experience in Japan is really difficult, but still.... The end result is two hours of bad acting on overlit sets. |
||||||||
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
||
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group