×
  • remind me tomorrow
  • remind me next week
  • never remind me
Subscribe to the ANN Newsletter • Wake up every Sunday to a curated list of ANN's most interesting posts of the week. read more

Review

by Reuben Baron,

Girl from the Other Side: Siúil, a Rún

Synopsis:
Fantasia Film Fest 2022: Girl from the Other Side: Siúil, a Rún
The world is divided in two, between the safe city of the Inside, and the dense and dangerous forest of the Outside. The security of the humans who live in the inside realm must be fiercely protected from the Outsiders, dark and monstrous creatures whose mere touch transmits their mysterious curse. Terrible tragedy strikes at the border of these two opposed realms, and among the dead, there is a sole survivor. This innocent girl, Shiva, is found by one of the shadowy Outsiders. With great care not to touch her, the beast assumes the role of her guardian, setting up a household for them in an abandoned village. She calls him Teacher. His compassion and patience towards her seems strangely human. The same cannot be said of the other Outsiders, lurking and watching from the woods...
Review:

In The Ancient Magus' Bride and Ranking of Kings, the animators at Wit Studio have shown themselves to be particularly adept at adapting fantasy manga that draw from classic fairy tales. Wit's latest fairy tale manga adaptation, The Girl from the Other Side, has elements of both series in its character archetypes — Teacher is a dapper and caring semi-humanoid monster a la Elias from Magus Bride and Shiva's adorable a child as Ranking of Kings' Bojji — while offering a truly unique experience.

Wit first adapted Nagabe's manga into a 10-minute short film in 2019. This feature-length OVA, which screened at the 2022 Fantasia Film Festival and will stream on Crunchyroll later this year, is still pretty short by feature standards with a runtime of only 70 minutes, five of which are credits. With its slow pace and emphasis on atmosphere over straightforward storytelling, however, this short movie nonetheless feels like the right length for what it's trying to accomplish; a longer version would require a different narrative approach.

The best thing about this film is its art and animation. Even in still moments, there's never any obvious animation shortcuts; the line drawings are always in some form of expressive motion. The closest comparison I can make is to The Tale of the Princess Kaguya, but with more Western influences in the design. The way they animate shadows and lighting effects is particularly stunning — the watercolor shading makes the images look three-dimensional without looking like CGI. It may be an OVA, but Crunchyroll should seriously consider putting this in theaters because the visuals would look incredible on the big screen.

The outstanding animation helps make the characters easy to emotionally connect with. Shiva's design tends toward minimalism: you can probably count the number of shots where she has a nose on one hand, and in wide shots her eyes become mere dots. That's all you really need to get across her joy, her excitement, her loneliness and fear. Teacher, with his demon-like face with no discernible mouth, is his own challenge to animate, but his eyes and body language prove the key to showing his emotions.

On its most basic level, this is a story of a dark, sad man finding joy and light in his life by protecting a young girl from the depressing world around them. Jun Fukuyama's deep-voiced performance as Teacher and Rie Takahashi's high-pitched Shiva fit the dark-light dynamic, though there are times it feels Takahashi is overdoing the cutesy kid voice (if this gets dubbed, I'd be curious to hear an actual child actor portray Shiva). Though some of the darker fantasy elements (scary flashbacks, a few scenes of violent knights, a turn towards a more plot-heavy climax) might make it debatable whether this truly counts as iyashikei or not, this film's atmospheric and thematic strengths fit solidly in with those of the “healing” genre.

Emphasizing vibes, rather than trying to adapt all of the plot from the 11-volume manga, leaves the world building intriguingly abstract. Some things about Teacher's curse are obvious (it spreads via touch, it erased his human memories, people are hunting him and others with the curse), while other aspects are left a bit more vague (it mostly turns people into animals but also sometimes they explode into trees? the corrupted don't have souls?). The film's climax, involving some crossings of borders between worlds, makes just enough sense to go with it, but it's still hard to follow just what exactly is going on moment-to-moment.

Even if I did not fully understand The Girl from the Other Side movie, it still made an emotional impact on me. In the simple yet strong archetypes of its characters and the astonishing beauty of its animation, this anime is a captivating work of art. It's genuinely shocking that this is directors Satomi Maiya and Yūtarō Kubo's first time directing a feature-length film — all anime fans should be paying attention to what these two do next.

Grade:
Overall : A-
Story : B
Animation : A+
Art : A+
Music : B

+ absolutely incredible animation, a charming iyashikei fantasy
don't expect to understand everything when the plot kicks in

discuss this in the forum (7 posts) |
bookmark/share with: short url

this article has been modified since it was originally posted; see change history

Add this anime to
Production Info:
Director:
Yūtarō Kubo
Satomi Maiya
Script:
Yūtarō Kubo
Satomi Maiya
Storyboard:
Takuto Katayama
Moe Koyano
Yūtarō Kubo
Satomi Maiya
Music: Schroeder-Headz
Character Design:
Yūtarō Kubo
Satomi Maiya
Art Director: Yūsuke Takeda
Animation Director: Namiko Tori
Sound Director: Shōji Hata
Director of Photography: Takeru Yokoi
Producer: Naokado Fujiyama
Licensed by: Crunchyroll

Full encyclopedia details about
Girl from the Other Side: Siúil, a Rún (OAV 2)

Review homepage / archives