Review

by Theron Martin,

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?: Arrow of the Orion

Blu-Ray

Synopsis:
Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?: Arrow of the Orion
It's Moon Festival time in Orario, and one of the feature events this year is a contest to pull free a spear-like weapon which is firmly embedded in crystals. Though stronger adventurers try, Bell Cranell, the Little Rookie, is the one who succeeds. As he and his compatriots soon learn, the trial is actually a test of worthiness to wield a divine weapon against a long-sealed-away monster who has started to emerge in a land far from Orario, and the sponsor is Artemis, the virgin goddess who was one of Hestia's closest friends in Heaven. But Artemis seems different to Hestia, and there are many things about this quest which seem suspicious. With Hestia, Welf, and Lily in tow, Bell travels with Hermes and Artemis to get to the bottom of the mystery. Meanwhile, back in Orario, other adventuring guilds are ominously being restricted from leaving the city.
Review:

Like many movies associated with anime TV series, Arrow of the Orion does not easily fit into the timeline established by the source novels. In fact, it technically doesn't fit at all. Circumstances shown in the movie indicate that it has to take place before Apollo Familia's attack (As seen in novel 6 and TV season 2 episode 3) and after Bell and crew return to the surface from the journey to floor 18 (at the end of novel 5 and TV season 1), but in the novels only a gap of a few days exists between the two; certainly there isn't room for the 20+ day round trip journey shown here. Franchise creator Fujino Ōmori, who also wrote the script for this movie, has implied that the movie isn't meant to be canon at all, and it is probably best interpreted that way anyway. That's a shame, as the movie features a surprisingly strong story for what's normally throwaway fare like this. In fact, it's one of the better non-canon movies out there which have been made as complement to a TV series.

Setting the timeline issue aside, the movie is deeply-grounded in the foundational elements of the franchise: Hestia and Lily squabbling with each other over Bell, Welf trying to stay out of it, and Hermes being the sly, manipulative horndog that he is. There's another female character – in fact, another goddess this time – involved who needs his assistance and seems to be getting drawn to him, hence providing further potential romantic complications, to Hestia and Lily's dismay. Predictably, there's also a task laid out that only one pure of heart and on a true heroic path can manage, and it involves dealing with an especially nasty foe that is also a complete Irregular as monsters go. That means lots of action sequences going around. A bunch of female characters gathered, including a goddess notorious in mythology for violent reactions to getting peeped upon while bathing, also gives Hermes another excuse for his more prurient side to show and provides much of the obligatory fan service.

If all of this sounds rather humdrum in construction, it is. However, this is also where characterizations and story execution matter most. Even if the story isn't canon, the details still flesh out the setting more by expanding Hestia's backstory and introducing something new: a deity who actually actively fights alongside her familia. It also demonstrates, more clearly than any animated content prior to the movie, why the gods locking their Arcanum away is such a big deal. Most importantly, the writing makes Artemis into a wholly credible character. It retains some of her defining characteristic from mythology but also shows that her circumstances and experiences in the mortal realm have changed her from what Hestia knew. She is now a creature of passion, one who seems determined to experience what she has not before, and yet all of her passion and warm smiles are tinged by a sadness and sense of resolution. The full reasons for this get revealed as the story approaches its climax, and the resolution of the whole affair is handled well enough to generate some emotional impact.

The naming conventions here are also interesting. In astronomy, Antares is a red star that is the brightest object in the constellation Scorpius, so it's not a coincidence that the monster by that name here looks somewhat like a giant, mutated scorpion. Scorpions are also integrally involved in stories concerning the legendary hunter Orion, and some version of Greek myths speak of Artemis taking a liking to Orion. Omori clearly took all of this into account in writing the story, which winds up being a variation on the myths involving Artemis, Orion, and Scorpio.

This being a movie connected to two TV series, it naturally has plenty of guest appearances. In addition to Bell, Hestia, Welf, and Lily all getting stylish new clothing for the adventure, just about every significant character from both the main series' first season and Sword Oratoria makes at least a brief cameo. In addition, several characters who first appear in the second season of the main series (which aired after this movie was released in Japan) also have very brief cameos in a montage near the end, including Aisha, Lena, and Haruhime. There is even a very obscure cameo: one character in the aforementioned montage is otherwise exclusive to the PC browser game DanMachi Orario Rhapsodia, which ran on Yahoo! Japan for several months between late 2017 and mid-2018.

For much of the movie the visuals are not substantially better than the TV series' normal level. Only in the featured action scenes and follow-ups near the end does the animation effort truly shine, providing a visual effect which surpasses the first season's peak efforts. The CG rendition of Antares and his minions is mostly effective, and some minor updates can be seen to the costuming of other characters if one watches closely. (Ryu is actually wearing shorts in her key appearances in the later stages, for instance.) The one wholly new character, Artemis, blends in well with the other designs and is convincing as a more athletic goddess.

The real production star, however, is the stellar musical effort. Keiji Inai's musical score for the TV series was a highlight, and he has outdone himself for the movie. While it does reuse key themes from the TV series, it remixes them fully to serve new purposes in the movie, in some cases thrusting them into entirely different tones and musical genres. The result is a sound that can at turns be playful, powerful, and even poignant. A variation of the TV series' main theme is used as the closer, and also listen for the lovely insert song “Tsukikagami.”

Sentai Filmworks' release of the movie brings back all of the vocal cast from the TV series. All acquit themselves at least as well here, and thankfully, the weird deviations seen in the last episode of the first TV season are not present here. Up-and-coming voice actress Avery Smithhart (Ange in Princess Principal) is also a strong fit in the one major new role as Artemis. Unfortunately the Blu-Ray release limits itself to just promo videos for Extras, so the bonuses included in the Japanese release will not be found here.

The one thing sadly missing from the movie is the tearjerker of an epilogue included with the movie's storyline in the Memoria Freeze game, though admittedly that wouldn't have fit well with bringing the story back down to Earth (and specifically Orario) at the very end. Overall, the movie succeeds well enough at what it's doing in its 82 minutes of run time to be worth a look by any franchise fan, even if how it fits into the main storyline has to be fudged.

Grade:
Overall (dub) : B+
Overall (sub) : B+
Story : B
Animation : B
Art : B+
Music : A-

+ Musical score, remarkably well-developed story, some late emotional appeal
Doesn't fit into canon storyline, occasionally weighted down by some of the weaker aspects of the TV series

discuss this in the forum (2 posts) |
bookmark/share with:
Add this anime to
Production Info:
Director: Katsushi Sakurabi
Script: Fujino Ōmori
Storyboard: Katsushi Sakurabi
Unit Director:
Katsushi Sakurabi
Yuuta Takamura
Shingo Uchida
Music: Keiji Inai
Original creator: Fujino Ōmori
Original Character Design: Suzuhito Yasuda
Character Design: Shigeki Kimoto
Art Director: Yasuhiro Okumura
Chief Animation Director: Shigeki Kimoto
Animation Director: Shigeki Kimoto
Sound Director: Jin Aketagawa
Director of Photography: Shingo Fukuyo

Full encyclopedia details about
Dungeon ni Deai o Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darō ka: Arrow of the Orion (movie)

Review homepage / archives