Review

by Lissa Pattillo, Apr 5th 2011

Toradora!

GN 1

Synopsis:
Toradora! GN 1
Takasu Ryuuji has gotten used to the assumptions people make about him based on his appearance. With scary eyes and a rather static expression, he's always been known as a delinquent regardless of the fact that he doesn't have a rap sheet. When starting his second year in high school he doesn't expect much to change but is optimistic when he discovers he's in the same class as his best friend and crush. Things get more complicated when he accidentally gets involved with the “Palmtop Tiger” Aisaka Taiga - the school's shortest, cutest and most dangerous student.
Review:

No one expects all manga to be thought-provoking masterpieces, but there's something to be said for a work that still manages to feel rather pointless. Toradora! achieves that with a claustrophobic focus on the lead characters and a plot that's shallow and cliche-ridden. In spite of all that, Toradora! still manages to be entertaining anyway, proving once again you don't need to have a deeper meaning to be fun.

Takasu Ryūji is an average teenage guy, excluding this nagging problem of looking like a criminal thanks to his uncontrollably aggressive stares. It doesn't seem to bother him much though and he's got bigger things on his mind anyway, like an OCD-driven need to have things kept clean. The new school year has begun and he's lucky enough to be in the same class as his best friend, Kitamura, and the girl he has a crush on, Kushieda.

Enter Aisaka Taiga. She's short, cute and nobody wants to mess with her. Ryūji soon learns she isn't all attitude and spunk however, no matter what the rumors their classmates circulate say. A love-letter acts as a catalyst to expose her cute insecurities, and she fiercely wields a boken in order to deal with them. If Taiga's dramatic introduction didn't already cinch the obvious, the events that soon follow drive home the fact that Ryūji has gotten himself involved with a girl destined to complicate things.

There's little to say about the standard 'boy meets girl and hijinks ensue' plot line but it feels like you're really taking this cliche premise on the chin when it's revealed they live next door to one another. Revealing that Taiga is in love with Kitamura and also happens to be close friends with Kushieda presents Taiga and Taksau with an obvious opportunity as they realize they're in love with the others' best friend. Dodgeball plots, failed attempts at baking and swirling rumors about the time they've begun spending together are just some of the beasts they battle. All the while Taiga prods Ryūji on like a slave driver as she uses her ability to get Ryūji closer to Kushieda against him. It's funny but also a little sad.

Were women not already enough trouble in Ryūji's life, you also have his mother. Her simple role as the busty, blush-cheeked eye-candy is as transparent as her lacy undergarments. She's selfish, lazy and just lays around the house whining cheerfully for Ryūji to feed her. It's almost impressive that despite this, her airheaded-nature somehow makes her hard to hate. Still, you'll be grateful she's only there part-time.

Kitamura and Kushieda are prominent in the book, but even they develop little past being one-dimensional plot devices. Kitamura is easy-going and good with girls, in contrast with Ryūji. Kushieda is the very definition of peppy and gets along with everyone, which contrasts with Taiga. The two spend quite a bit of time together as members of the student council and there's an underlying sense that they know more of what's going on than they let on. Or perhaps it's something else altogether. Either way the volume ends on a cliffhanger when readers see Kushieda being a lot more serious than we were lead to believe was possible.

By this point readers have been given just enough reason to care about how things play out for Ryūji and Taiga. It's easy to pity Ryūji for what he goes through with Taiga, and surprisingly easy to feel sympathy for Taiga for her earnest, tongue-tied attempts to talk to Kitamura. At the same time the plot itself still feels uninspired – haven't we read similar stories far too many times before?

Fortunately Seven Seas does a great job playing up the series' stronger points with exceptional adaptation work. There was a lot of care taken with the way characters speak, including the use of bolds and italics to put emphasis on specific words. A little bit of slang and intentionally sloppy grammar tailor the speech perfectly to teenagers as well.

This version of Toradora! also benefits greatly from Zekkyō's artwork which brings an energy to the story that the plot itself can sometimes lack. It's cute, lively and oftentimes hilarious, especially given the weird expressions on the cast's faces, Taiga's in particular. The style lends itself best to her, especially when she's having scattered moments of teary-eyed sadness or an honest smile, all of which are given special attention by the artist.

Toradora! won't win many points for originality yet its eccentricities make this a decent first volume. Both Taiga and Ryūji have their own special issues played for our entertainment. It's amusing seeing how they clash. The story's romance is a little hard to care about though when there's more chemistry between them than the targets of their affections. But that's likely intentional, as we can see a relationship between the Palmtop Tiger and her servant coming a mile away. It's this feeling that Toradora! is just another trope-coasting plot that holds it back. Thankfully often over the top characters and cute artwork prove how this kind of otaku-targeted material still manages to find an audience nearly every time anyway.

Grade:
Production Info:
Overall : B
Story : C+
Art : A-

+ Charming, fun artwork and a lively story to match; contrasting elements of Taiga's personality make her entertaining alongside Ryuuji
Sports the cliches and fanservice that make it feel more otaku-only written than able to appeal to a broader audience; predictable plot that overshadows the scattered moments where the characters are actually entertaining

Original creator:Yuyuko Takemiya
Original Character Design:Yasu
Art:Zekkyō

Full encyclopedia details about
Toradora! (manga)

Release information about
Toradora! (GN 1)

discuss this in the forum (12 posts) |
bookmark/share with:

Add this manga to

Add this Graphic novel to

Review homepage / archives

Around The Web