Read some
Black Butler (manga)
Bleach (manga)
Blue Exorcist (manga)
Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic (manga)
Oh My Goddess! (manga)

I'll admit that my rating system is not quite objective and is based more on how much I enjoyed the show than in its production values or whatever. I tend to give extra points to shows that make me nostalgic -Saint Seiya and Digimon are good examples of this. I also really take into account whether the show achieved what it attempted to, and whether it delivered what it promised. Some ratings are not exactly how I feel about a show, I seriously feel a "forgettable" and "memorable" rate should be available. "Mediocre" and "hilariously awful", would be fab too.

Read all Rating
Angelic Layer (manga)
Bakuman. (manga)
Ouran High School Host Club (manga) Excellent