Why is Stain's Capture Actually Good for the League of Villains?
by Nicholas Dupree and Michelle Liu,
Everyone in My Hero Academia is recovering after their terrifying encounter with Hero Killer Stain, but maybe they shouldn't be getting too comfortable. This week in anime, we explain why the real battle is only beginning.
Disclaimer:The views and opinions expressed by the participants in this chatlog are not the views of Anime News Network.
Don't be silly, you can never be too old for anime, death itself be damned.
I guess I can't feel too old considering I still get up every saturday morning to watch superhero cartoons.
But you mean the other Saturday superhero show, right? The one with the pure good children.
Yes, that one
Yeah, so this week MHA decided to go Anime Original and focused a whole episode on America's Favorite Frog.
move aside, kermit, it's tsuyu time
But we're Hard. Core. Canonists. So instead we're gonna be talking about the real star of this series:
I'm so down for bloodthirsty schoolgirl villain, can't wait can't wait
I just meant that she's symbolic of the encroaching spread of villainy in the wake of Stain's capture actually. But if that's what you're into, I won't judge you
I'm just saying if MHA decides to become the Himiko and Froppy Show I wouldn't be upset at all. But yeah, last time we saw Stain get captured, but that's not the end of his influence by any means.
Nope! Turns out the real villain of MHA was kids on YouTube. It's an interesting direction to take though - it reminds me of the end of momentous story arcs in One Piece, where the focus temporarily shifts to the world at large and how the fallout is changing things outside of our main cast. Stain's been caught, but the most viral thing in the world is an idea, and unlike Shigaraki, Stain's conviction spoke for itself.
Plus, look at all the media coverage he got. I'm sure that's not inspiring anyone to act out haha
It's eerily similar to the, for lack of a better term, "fandom" that forms around infamous serial killers and the like. Stain's a murderer, but to the average person who doesn't have to fear him directly, his story is basically entertainment.
MHA's addressing the situation in a way that's almost uncomfortably real. People eat up the story they're fed, that he's captured, that's the end of it, but those who don't turn to alternative sources - in this case, the internet. You get enough folks to realize there's an outlet for their less savory opinions and coalesce around that conviction, now you've got a movement on your hands. Who knew the real league of villains was an angry subforum all along?
What's interesting to me is the way it's compared to the cult of personality All Might's fostered in his time.
We've seen the positive influence he's had throughout the show - Deku, Todoroki, and countless others have been inspired by him to become heroes and do good in the world. But it's pretty fair to say All Might was Stain's inspiration too - and he used the "Symbol of Peace" as a benchmark to justify killing and injuring dozens of "lesser" heroes.
Now Stain's turning into the inspiration for people with, uh, alternative ideas of what's right/correct/morally good.
And they're all being funneled into the League of Villains - led by a manchild who we already know will pay lip service to anti-establishment rhetoric to justify his real motive to destroy whatever he wants! Yayyyyyyy...
we sure haven't heard anything like this ever before, nope nope
IMO it's a fascinating place to go for a superhero story. Especially MHA, which has always posited that true heroism inspires others to act in turn. In a lot of ways, Stain's an interrogation of the show's underlying themes, which is really neat to see.
Yeah, aside from the whole killing people part, Stain could easily be twisted into a hero: someone using their powers to improve society and make the world a better place, inspiring others to do the same. Like if you can look past the murder, that's a pretty solid goal. If you can manage those mental gymnastics, I mean. For the people in MHA's world who don't have a personal attachment to Stain's victims, that might be a little easier than it should be. So yeah, he's becoming this twisted version of All Might in the popular consciousness, for better or for worse. Mostly for worse.
What's ironic is that Stain's actions are being made as public as possible, while Deku and friends aren't even allowed to speak about what really happened.
For all the general public knows, Stain was only targeting heroes like Endeavor - stickin it to the man or something
The media story isn't "hero children save lives" but "murderer maybe had a point if you think about it". It's depressing to say the least.
But hey, look, the police chief's a puppy!
Puppers and froggos can only do so much to make the whole thing less depressing though : (
I'll just take comfort knowing that at some point in time Kohei Horikoshi definitely saw Dog Police
But yeah, it'll be interesting to see where MHA goes from here with all this. This feels like a pretty big turning point, even if we might not see the full extent quite yet.
I'm just fascinated by how it's tackling the way media can radicalize dissatisfied people. Looking forward to seeing what kinds of villains crop up soon, and not just for the stabby girl.
Until now, the League of Villains was basically Shigaraki, his talking TV set, and a group of randos. But now it's gonna have characters! With names! And ridiculous designs like this walking Hot Topic store
oh my god, that's some real A e s t h e t i c right there
Well before everything goes to hell, how 'bout that Froppy?
I can't believe she joined the navy seals, er, navy seal
I can't believe we got a close up of his starboard bow
Tired: boob shots Wired: humanoid seal bulge
Hey, there's room for boob shots too
I look forward to more buff skintight suit seal action in next week's episode of Froppy's Wet 'n' Wild Adventure.
Or I guess we can go back to the heroes and villains stuff if we HAVE to...
You've heard of ship girls (KanColle) and sword boys (Touken Ranbu), but these anthropomorphized anime characters are on another level of weirdness.― When I first wrote about wacky dating sims, it seemed like the anthro-craze was just starting to get off the ground. Ship girls and sword boys weren't quite mainstream and the weirdest examples to come stateside involved pigeons and llamas. At the tim...
While the Madarame harem arc has gone on far too long, this volume manages to find some of this series' strongest nuggets of drama in its twists and turns. Nick Creamer digs in.― Genshiken's Madarame harem arc has gone on for a long, long time. It felt like an unrealistic nod to the original Genshiken's breakout character from the start, and since then, it's wound through so many repetitive turns th...
2017 was a HUGE year for video games, so we've got a HUGE podcast counting down our Top 5 Games of 2017, with an all-star panel!― ANNCast Episode 314 - Games of the Year 2017 2017 was a HUGE year for video games, so we've got a HUGE podcast counting down our Top 5 Games of 2017, featuring Dave and Graziella from Friends from the Internet, Dustin Bailey, formerly of This Week in Games, and Heidi Kem...
Fox has the merchandise rights for Alita: Battle Angel, but James Cameron's company has the film rights. How does all of this work, anyway? Justin gets into it.― Jason asked: Fox had Alita: Battle Angel available at Licensing Expo in Vegas. Which parts of James Cameron's agreement with manga artist Yukito Kishiro is between him & Kishiro, compared to james cameron's a:ba merch agreement with fox? D...
From the East Blue to Whole Cake Island, Sam Leach breaks down the top ten adventures of the Straw Hat crew and invites you to share your own favorite episodes of this legendary series.― If there's a series that seeks to challenge the theory of diminishing returns, it's One Piece. Eiichiro Oda's monstrous epic is the highest selling manga of all time, but its absurd length still keeps plenty of peop...
The series stumbles a bit with this poorly paced volume, but Naofumi's rise nonetheless continues. Rebecca Silverman has the details.― It's a good thing that this is the final book in the “other other world” arc, because while there is technically enough plot to round the volume out, it is feeling a little thin. The book is focused on Naofumi and his party finally taking out Kyo, the maniac with the...
Blood Blockade Battlefront & Beyond reaches for the top of the charts with a standout episode, while Dragon Ball Super comes down from its recent high. Find out where all your favorite series ranked this week!― Our team of reviewers are following 31 anime series of the Fall 2017 season and readers are rating each episode as the reviews go up. So let's have a look at what ANN readers consider the be...
Welcome to the Ballroom began as one of the most anticipated shows of the summer, but enthusiasm has dropped off sharply since then. We look back on what went wrong as the series waltzes toward its conclusion.― Welcome to the Ballroom began as one of the most anticipated shows of last summer season, but enthusiasm has dropped off sharply since then. This week in anime, Nick and Jake track the series...
The director of this summer's steampunk spy smash success Princess Principal goes in-depth on the show - and even discusses sequel potential!― Princess Principal is an anime set in an alternate-history steampunk version of Victorian London, following a group of five ladies, professional spies who find themselves embroiled in a game of mistaken identities and political intrigue. The show's incredible...
Heidi breaks down this week's explosion of news following The Game Awards: Street Fighter EX, new Soul Calibur, and Norman Reedus's fantastic fetus!― THIS WEEK IN GAMES: IT'S A NEWZAPALOOZA Jeez, I expected to have a whole ton of news to write about this week, but somehow news kept on flooding in even after the Game Awards and the PSX keynote! (Which, by the way, I was totally wrong about – the Game...
This isekai story starts a cut above the rest with a focus on multiple protagonists and one very unfortunate eight-legged reincarnation. Theron Martin explains what makes this series an engrossing read.― Isekai (“transported to another world”) stories have dominated the Japanese light novel market over the past few years. This take on the concept is the second to be released recently in English in r...
Our big fall manga guide has one last surprise update, with FIVE new December manga reviews!
Available Now: One Week Friends - Graineliers - So I'm A Spider, So What? - A Terrified Teacher At Ghoul School - Angels of Death - Shiver - Splatoon - Astra Lost in Space - Neo Parasyte M - Card Captor Sakura: Clear Card - and much more!― Welcome to Anime News Network's Fall Manga Guide! You may have see...
They're still showing 35mm prints of Ghibli classics like Princess Mononoke in some revival theaters - but what's so special about 35mm? Justin has some thoughts.― David asked: Hi! I've noticed that several art house theaters in the NY metro area have started showing 35mm version of Ghibli classics like Mononoke and Nausicaa. is there any real benefit to seeing these over the "regular versions" mor...
From She and Her Cat to Your Name., Anne Lauenroth ranks all of Makoto Shinkai's projects from top to bottom. What are your favorite creations by this distinctive director?― Why do we wake up crying from a dream we've already begun to forget? Why does the feeling of loss linger after the memory of that dream has faded to a vague feeling of something that should be there but isn't? How can we long f...
Corpse Party's conclusion diverges more from the game than ever before, but disappoints as a horror story. Rebecca Silverman explains what went wrong.― These volumes, according to creators Toshimi Shinomiya and Makoto Kedouin, are where the manga adaptation of Corpse Party: Blood Covered really diverges from its game original. By this point the cast is most cut back down to its first game characters...