Forum - View topic

anohana: The Flower We Saw That Day (TV).

We already have proof that she's a ghost. There was the scene where she hugged Anaru and said "My neck feels heavy", meaning she felt Menma touch her. Then there was the scene at her old home where she accidentally knocked over the glass of water. She's definitely a ghost, but for some reason she's physically aged, but not as much as the others, and still has the mental capacity of when she died.

Personally, I think the only reason they "aged" her is so that they can have those scenes were she inadvertantly sexually excites Dude without it being *too* lolicious.

it happens on many anime, why not?

One thing I can't quite figure out is Menma's appearance. She's not as young as she was when she died, but she's still several years younger than everyone else. It's like she died at 6, everyone else is 15, but she's about 11-12. And she even acts and talks like she did when she was younger.

Spotlesseden wrote:

it happens on many anime, why not?

Name three.

Also, there was the thing with the dog that could see her.

We already have proof that she's a ghost. There was the scene where she hugged Anaru and said "My neck feels heavy", meaning she felt Menma touch her. Then there was the scene at her old home where she accidentally knocked over the glass of water. She's definitely a ghost, but for some reason she's physically aged, but not as much as the others, and still has the mental capacity of when she died.

Index, there was a ghost girl that created by someone imagination.

07 Ghost, so many imagination things.

Bleach: Memory of Nobody.

Haruhi Suzumiya, I'm not sure what's real in that anime.

I'll give the benefit of the doubt to Echo City. He listed ghost-like characters that were something else and wonders if she's something similar, not the exact same thing, presumably.

Not that I agree.