Forum - View topic

Your thoughts on "American" anime?

What he was saying was that you shouldn't try to imitate Japan.

I mean, I think we're too quick to throw around the words "right" and "wrong" when it comes to Americans imitating anime. It's better to say "To become a professional animator, it's best not to copy from something else, otherwise you might not get very far".
But if they're doing it as an online hobby and they got popular enough to have a fanbase, who are we to tell them "that's not right"/"that shouldn't be how you draw"/"your work shouldn't be a Japanese cultural piece if you're not Japanese".
No, we don't have the right to tell them that's "wrong". Who are they hurting?

To be honest though, I frankly don't care too much if that never happens. I'm already getting my fair dose of these kind of shows when I watch them and when I read, so there's little point in me begging American animators to make something like The Tatami Galaxy when I don't think they can necessarily do a great job with it.

Oh, you have no how many, whom I have come across -- whose feelings have been hurt by the concept of American produced anime and manga.

Quote:

To be honest though, I frankly don't care too much if that never happens. I'm already getting my fair dose of these kind of shows when I watch them and when I read, so there's little point in me begging American animators to make something like The Tatami Galaxy when I don't think they can necessarily do a great job with it.

This is one of the most irritating beliefs I see expressed frequently.

What, so we can't try to fix the american animation industry? We should just go "Well, I have anime so I don't need anything else"? Bullshit. I'd rather try to fix the American industry in some way so we get some like Tatami Galaxy, or Techolyze, made here. It may take years, but the more well-made animated works that get made, the better.

You just sound so...defeatist.

But americans are still showing Family Guy and Venture Bros to their 6-year-olds just like they're letting them play GTA because they haven't broken away from the "this is for kids" mindset. Until that mindset is completely discarded by the masses progress in this area can't happen because there's no money in it.

The problem is I just don't see a Texhnolyze, Mushishi, Ergo Proxy, or Kuuchuu Buranko animated show being made here in the states. That's just not something America has interest in, IMO.

And as for episode 3, yay, group dynamics! So much fun. It's like oil and water - 2 extraverts and 2 bitc--introverts. I still really like Blake, despite her cold shoulder.

I'm happy to see that Yang didn't just forget about her sister. Obviously in the future they're going to be on the same team, but even leading up to that point it's not just, "OH! My friends are here! C-ya!" She still held a spot for her at the opening ceremony and then later slept next to her. I love seeing sisters that tease and goof off with each other.

It almost seems like Ruby doesn't really know what Dust is. Or maybe she knows about it, but doesn't really understand it. Given how the the first episode started, you'd think she would, but she seemed kind of confused that there was an explosion and then ice. It makes me wonder how well known and understood Dust really is at this point by the general public. Or maybe it's just Ruby growing up not knowing much about it. Her and Yang's weapons don't have anything to do with Dust.

Thinking back on the first four videos, each character fought an entirely different entity. Ruby's was wolves/beasts, Weiss' Big Armor seemed to be power by some sort of magic/Dust, Blake's was robots, and Yang's was humans. So it seems like there are four different forces that could potentially become antagonists. It kind of makes me wonder if their weapons are better suited for different fights. Yang's strength and gauntlets, as awesome as they are, might not be so effective against robots. And considering that three of the four girls fight with sharp edges, are we actually going to see people get killed in this series?

But back to the third episode. Professor Ozpin's speech... "all I see is wasted energy in need of purpose." N'aw, man, c'mon, tell us what you REEEEEEAAAAALLLLLY think. It was pretty effective at setting a more serious tone, probably alluding to where the series will eventually go.

And then there's Blake's book, a tale of a man with two souls each fighting for control over his body (her eyes got the widest I've seen for her when she said that - aw...). I wonder who that alludes to. Adam? Blake? Or is it just a general statement about the duality of humanity? Is it taken literally, metaphorically, or both?

And the trend continues, making Jaune out as the dorky buttmonkey. But I love him precisely because of that. I find it amusing that it was the word "scraggly" that got his attention when Weiss was describing him. And then later with the pjs.

That pjs scene all-together was great. A bunch of men, bare from the waist up, clearly posing for all the ladies. Free! isn't the only series this season with that kind of fanservice.

But I was actually paying more attention to the ladies in their pjs. Those shoulders. Damn, we finally get some muscle tone! I really appreciated that.

Overall, great episode! It was funny, had some good dynamic-building scenes, and even edged in a little fanservice (both girls and guys).

Looking forward to more next week!

It's not the "animation is for kids" mindset, Japan has literally the exact same thing, just rather unique circumstances led to animation for "adults" (because most anime is not really for adults, most of it's for teenagers/adults with the mindset of teenagers) being a niche subculture and not utterly stamped out completely like in the west.

My pipe dream is to write a successful books, make millions off that then commission an anime of said book, using my immense wealth and excellent persuasive skills to get it on TV.