Forum - View topic

NEWS: Netflix Reveals Trailer for 4th Season of Castlevania Animated Show

OMG who cares about the lore?? it's based off a video game from 30 years ago that couldn't keep it's own lore straight. These are some petty criticisms, and I'd take clever character writing and great natural dialogue over "accurate character portrayal" any day.

doubleO7 wrote:

I have to agree with the other guy, as a huge Castlevania fan Warren Ellis was my least favorite thing about the show. The final product was a decent vampire action series, but a poor Castlevania adaptation. He butchered the lore and characters, cut a main cast member for silly reasons, and by his own admission knew nothing about Castlevania before writing it. I honestly think it could've been even better than it was had the show not diverged so drastically from certain aspects of the source material as it went on. I, for one, can't wait to see what another writer (ideally, an actual fan of the series) does with the franchise going forward, assuming those rumors about potential follow-up series starring different Belmonts pan out.

It's still a western adaption at the end of the day - with or without Warren Ellis isn't going to change that. When has a western adaption, especially one based on a Japanese IP, ever been faithful and accurate to the source material? Not even western franchises like The Witcher can get faithful adaptions. I don't see any reason to think future installments would be much better.

Scion Drake wrote:

From what I got Castlevania is one of those franchises that focuses more on gameplay over lore or story. So it’s essentially either incoherent or inconsistent from game to game especially the characters, because the only things that really mattered is the atmosphere and general gameplay of fighting Dracula. .

Castlevania has plenty of lore, stories, and characters in the games themselves. Not only that, but there's been manga adaptions of the games over the years that have been perfectly fine. Even disregarding all that, it's still possible to do better than what we got. The Netflix show was the equivalent of making an adaption of Dragon Ball where Goku is a pacifist who hates fighting and Vegeta hates being a Saiyan and despises his heritage. The bar is very low to not to assassinate characters to that degree.

Eh last time I checked Trevor's own characterization varies from product to product. His character here is no more valid than any other version thats already existed, its not really character assassination or anything to that degree.

Especially if we're talking characters like Isaac who were pretty awful in their original versions and how they appear on the show is leagues better.

So, I'm guessing this isn't just gonna be Curse of Darkness...ah well

Good riddance....glad I'm not the only person that couldn't stand this "adaptaion"

It's still a western adaption at the end of the day - with or without Warren Ellis isn't going to change that. When has a western adaption, especially one based on a Japanese IP, ever been faithful and accurate to the source material? Not even western franchises like The Witcher can get faithful adaptions.

From what I got Castlevania is one of those franchises that focuses more on gameplay over lore or story.

I'm puzzled to hear the dialogue in Ellis's Castlevania described as 'natural'. The never-ending stream of topical politicisms, modern-teenager bickering between the main cast, and e.g. viking-vampires exaggerated to the point of dull hyperbole were exactly what I disliked most about it.

Especially if we're talking characters like Isaac who were pretty awful in their original versions and how they appear on the show is leagues better.

I'm puzzled to hear the dialogue in Ellis's Castlevania described as 'natural'. The never-ending stream of topical politicisms, modern-teenager bickering between the main cast, and e.g. viking-vampires exaggerated to the point of dull hyperbole were exactly what I disliked most about it.

My memory and knowledge of the Castlevania lore is pretty vague so most of the changes didn’t bother me, but characters frequently devolving into children throwing inane and witless insults back and forth was one of the most annoying things for me. Trevor essentially grew up by the end of the first season which could have been a good enough character arc, but in many ways he’s back to normal shortly afterwards. Then other characters (including Alucard who’s intended to have some level of dignity and wit) randomly act identically regardless of whether it’s completely out of character. At least give them some clever insults or inventive curses.

People like Joss Whedon and Brian Michael Bendis pretty much created the landscape for this kind of dialog to be considered the norm when writing these kinds of shows. I've never really been a fan of snarky one liners or any other kind of Buffspeak/Bendisspeak that has become the standard for geek media since the 90s, but a lot of people do and pretty much expect it. It definitely feels out of place for Castlevania, though.