Forum - View topicANNCast - Viewers Like You: Blood and Ecchi
Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 Next Note: this is the discussion thread for this article |
Author | Message | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Thunderbird-
Posts: 60 |
|
|||
Well, this is just great! I preordered the K-on! and The Girl Who Leapt Through Time BDs from Right Stufs Bandai sale and now I'm going to be paranoid that they're not going to work.
|
||||
einhorn303
Posts: 1180 |
|
|||
I think Justin's comments about "jumping into the middle of things" makes a lot of sense for me, since that's what I love about Science Fiction (literature). I remember reading Samuel R. Delaney's "Stars in my Pocket Like Grains of Sand" as a teenager. For the first few pages, I had literally no idea what the hell anything meant. But then I kept reading, and found it fascinating. It's the sort of writing that's dense, and builds its own world.
And Zac should stay far away from the Golden Age trilogy, whose first page begins with lines like "Phaethon had been imagining the evening, perhaps, would be in miniature, for Rhadamanthus House, what the High Transcendence in December would be for all mankind. But he was disappointed. The review of one drab and uninspired extrapolation after another had drained his patience. Here was a future where all men were recorded as brain-information in a diamond logic crystal occupying the core of earth; there was another where all humanity existed in the threads of a plantlike array of sails and panels forming a Dyson Sphere around the sun..." |
||||
Zac
ANN Executive Editor
Posts: 7912 Location: Anime News Network Technodrome |
|
|||
But even in this there are a few key seeds of exposition and some really interesting concepts, enough to make me curious to read more. I suppose I should've clarified further - drop me into a confusing situation all you want, but that confusion needs to be compelling and interesting. If it's confusing AND just an obvious uninspired mishmash of extremely familiar visual cues, character types and sci-fi nonsense lifted from a dozen well-trod places, I'm out. |
||||
Animehermit
Posts: 964 Location: The Argama |
|
|||
somehow people seem to think that you just hate in medias res. |
||||
einhorn303
Posts: 1180 |
|
|||
I guess one issue is that, in this case, compelling and interesting work better as verbs than adjectives; not "This is interesting/compelling", but "This interests/compels me." They're rather subjective. For sure I watch shows just because character designs/archetypes shown off at the beginning interest me. Like Laura Bodewig from Infinite Stratos (maybe that's a bad example since I've ended up finding the show rather meh). |
||||
mglittlerobin
Posts: 1071 |
|
|||
Welcome to the internet. Where people are stupid. |
||||
dizzon
Posts: 338 |
|
|||
I still have the original Record of Lodoss War on VHS cassette so it's definitely a high nostalgia buy if/when Media Blasters puts it out, especially on Blu-ray which I'm not holding my breath for though I would be super pumped if actualized.
Here's an old title I'd like to see rescued and given a quality re-release even though I'm pretty sure I would be the only one excited or actually pay money for it....Green Legend Ran. Just me? Ok, yeah just me... |
||||
nintendonut100
Posts: 2 |
|
|||
and since everyone's giving their opinions on echi I haven't seen any so I can't judge but fanservice in a normal show normaly gets on my nerves but hey I also hate large amounts of violence for the most part because it often seems to be used as a cop out sortta like they are saying "I can't think of anything to do plot wise here have gore"!
|
||||
Errinundra
Moderator
Posts: 6536 Location: Melbourne, Oz |
|
|||
Thanks to Calathan and the character guessing game thread I recently watched Green Legend Ran via YouTube. It's not bad at all. Sure, the anime style shows its age but there are several stunning scenes. |
||||
MarcFBR
Posts: 47 Location: California |
|
|||
Recently Bandai disks have been fine outside of the odd off problems (mono audio on the Haruhi stuff.) Any personal paranoia of mine is from remembering the especially bad Bandai days and the (many) past problems Bandai had (paranoia is mostly from their old tendency to NOT admit there was a problem.) Their current disks are generally fine and there isn't really any reason to not get them. If Bandai is doing something I want I generally will get it as soon as I can, as should you if you can afford it. |
||||
agila61
Posts: 3213 Location: NE Ohio |
|
|||
Though, unintentionally, this may have revealed the rationale behind the "gore plus boobies" combo. "Its just so unrealistic that Ikki has all these fights that are massive enough to knock people's clothes off without ever having any body parts go flying too. It makes it hard to pretend that we're watching it for the fight scenese." "Ah, if you need some body parts flying around to keep up the pretense, we're happy to oblige."
"Not getting it", though ~ that's the formula behind lots of C grade "horror" films, its hard to credit that supposed film aficionados are puzzled by it. |
||||
Shenl742
Posts: 1524 |
|
|||
So basically Freezing is just a gorier, sluttier version of My-Otome?
|
||||
einhorn303
Posts: 1180 |
|
|||
As someone who's finding Freezing his favorite show of the season, that's not at all how the appeal works for me. To me a lot of Freezing's appeal lies in its extreme version of tragedy-moe. Bad things happen to the main heroine and you feel sorry and protective of her; Freezing just takes that to an absurd and brutal height. Every single episode is a new case of unfair bullying perpetrated on Satellizer. And in episode 7 her story gets even more tragic, what with spoiler[her childhood of living with a step family who hated and sexually abused her, topped off with her sickly mother dying in her arms]. Freezing takes tragedy-moe out of the world of wistful sighs and disappearing girls (think Fuuko's arc in Clannad) and into a gritty, Lord of the Flies-like realm. Without the blood and guts you just don't have that. I haven't been able to see Madoka, but based on the complaints about it appealing based on cruelty to children (spoiler[Mami getting her head bit off and all]), it might be a similar extension of moe. Another interesting way to read Freezing, when Satellizer inevitably turns the table on her attackers each episode with some unknown power-up, is as an anime version of anti-bully revenge fantasies. The sort scribbled in the notebooks of teenagers in all post-industrialized countries.
If you want to massively over-simplify things, yeah. Sort of like saying The Bluest Eye is a darker, sluttier version of To Kill a Mockingbird." In many key aspects the two shows are completely different, though. |
||||
CG-LOVER
Posts: 355 Location: East Lansing, MI |
|
|||
I liked Ranma. >_> And it also wasn't the first lengthy show I'd seen either. And I DID watch all of it too so there ya go Zac. Yeah it's a lot of the same and it got tiresome of times but it had its moments. |
||||
CG-LOVER
Posts: 355 Location: East Lansing, MI |
|
|||
This. And to go even further I buy a fair amount of their current releases and don't experience any problems either with only a couple exceptions. One is that there is a grammatical error in the description on the back cover of their recent My-Otome OVA release, but that hardly matters. Also, when I first purchased my Code Geass part 1 DVD set there were those issues with the second disc that everyone talked about for a while. HOWEVER, I gave that disc one run through my Blu-ray player and since then it has worked perfectly regardless of what player I use for it. So really I've been quite satisfied with all of the BANDAI releases I've received. I was curious about something though. In terms of spelling issues with show descriptions Zac mentioned that some of Eureka Seven's DVD descriptions were off. Is that from an older release or something, because I'm looking at my two Anime Legends Complete Collection sets and I'm not really seeing anything wrong there. Moving on, as far as the discussion on remakes goes I thought that the guest may have been too harsh when referring to those first 13 episodes of FMA: Brotherhood. I have NOT seen the original show but there's no way that those 13 eps. of Brotherhood are nearly as bad as he's making them out to be. And as far as what version to watch first, I actually consciously made the decision to go with the remake first. I mean why not? This version is supposed to be far truer to the manga so I thought it was a no-brainer (and since then, I have pretty much fallen in love with the show). Finally, I want to mention the discussion about fanservice. Mainly that I would also love the idea of there being an episode devoted to determining what qualifies as "tasteful" fanservice. I'm just curious since I get the feeling that while I do dislike fanservice when it is is too forcefully applied, or rather is just shoehorned into a show (the most recent example I think of is High School of the Dead. Honestly, it's just laughable), I may be a bit more forgiving than Zac when it comes to how the fanservice is explicitly presented within said show. I also find it a bit funny when Zac mentioned a guy falling on a girl's breasts is "tastless" fanservice, when that exact example happened in NGE with Shinji and Rei; a show Zac said had "tasteful" fanservice. |
||||
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
||
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group