Forum - View topicNEWS: 4Kids Profit Falls Again
Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 Next Note: this is the discussion thread for this article |
Author | Message | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Steventheeunuch
|
|
|||||||
That could very well be the case, but they've already said that they're trying to establish their own brands and franchises, rather than relying on foreign animation and licensed goods (That whole Chaotic thing, etc)
It might make them a profit, but it wouldn't make them such a huge, substantial profit, not one they'd expect. They've also gone on record to say that the profit they seek/feel worthwhile isn't from DVD sales, but rather toys, games, etc (as they were going to offer their media for free). Anyway, after the fiasco of Shaman King and Yugioh, it doesn't look like they're going back. TV series of Anime, even uncut, don't make as much as you think they would.
Don't defend retards, it doesn't help you one iota. Public lambasting only helps seperate wheat from chaff, and I'd rather not be on a forum where something like that is easily (and usually is) dealt with. |
||||||||
TNaran
Posts: 17 Location: Canada |
|
|||||||
WTF... How did you reach THAT conclusion!? Pokemon??? Cartoon Network did more to bring anime to the mainstream than 4Kids ever did. As well, look at the anime non-otaku people point to that brought them in: * Robotech (Harmony Gold) * Sailor Moon (DiC) * Dragonball (FUNimation) * Akira (Streamline originally) (See the poll on this site, as well anecdotal evidence from various anime forums) Where do you see 4Kids in there? I'm sure Pokemon got some of the younger generation in, but the market is much bigger than them. If anything, their Pokemon license might have pushed back the cause by permanently associating anime in the mainstream mind with children shows that market toys and video games.
Tell me... do you continue to patronize restaurants that always give you food poisoning, stores that sell you broken merchandise and haircutters who give you bad hair cuts? 4Kids deserves no loyalty for their bad service. Sandy Frank didn't treat Gatchaman as badly as 4Kids treated its anime properties. Voyager entertainment Westernized Space Battleship Yamato, managed to fit within TV broadcast standards and still made it a good show. 4Kids treated their properties like crap and figured kids couldn't give a damn. And guess what: kids have some taste and that's why they didn't watch, and thus why 4Kids is suffering downturns despite their hand-waving of "restructuring, one-time charges, etc." Hoping they get better? I hope they go bankrupt so the licenses can be re-assigned to companies that care about producing a decent product. Last edited by TNaran on Mon Aug 14, 2006 9:51 pm; edited 1 time in total |
||||||||
Amibite
Posts: 196 |
|
|||||||
Hate 4kids dubs all you want, but they are responsible for helping anime become more mainstream in America. Pokemon has done wonders for opening up the gateway for more anime to be liscenced and brought over here. While anime did exist here before Pokemon (notably Speed Racer, Robotech, and Dragonball Z) they were no where near as popular as Pokemon was back in its big boom (and Dragonball Z is probably the only one of those three that people knew it was from Japan)
I could care less on what your opinion is for their dubbing procedures, but if people are going to plug their ears and pretend 4Kids has done nothing for the anime market, they should just stop watching anime right now.
You're logic is horribly flawed. You're directing us to anime websites run by fans to see whats popular. Anime fans are in the minority. The mainstream (as in, most of America) would know about Pokemon much more than the titles you listed. Whats the fanbase finds popular and what the mainstream finds popular is two completely different things. |
||||||||
tidusora
Posts: 65 |
|
|||||||
Wrong, Wrong, we never said that 4kids didn't start anything for the anime market. They did indeed release some popular titles for a chilren audience, which helped expand the thought to children thinking this was American Cartoons rather than Anime. It did contribute though. We're just saying that 4kids didn't start it all, with Pokemon, like everyone says. We're stating that there were anime way before Pokemon that helped contribute to the anime market. |
||||||||
Ivyna J Spyder
Posts: 1 |
|
|||||||
...Man I'm hoping I just read that wrong and you did NOT just badmouth Kirby. :( Seriously, that show got the WORST image because of the dub. One Piece at least has the uncut manga to save it, Kirby got turned into crap by the dub. And because no one subbed it (until recently :D I'm up to ep 33...) it didn't have a previous fanbase. So really, if you've only seen the dub, don't judge it on that. It's a freaking sweet show and was popular in Japan. |
||||||||
OneHotAlchemist
Posts: 85 |
|
|||||||
I'll be sorry about 4kids going bankrupt the day they have a panel at an anime convention. Its a two-way street. Even if 4kids somehow helped further anime into the mainstream, it does nothing but defecate onto the very people who post on this forum and read this website. 4kids is also JUST as to blame for not bringing anime further into mainstream, by your own logic, with their failure in OP. |
||||||||
kei-clone
Posts: 23 Location: in your house |
|
|||||||
eh, misquotings...I didn't write those, terek did. other than that, thanks to tidusora and OneHotAlchemist for the responses - pretty much my thoughts exactly. saved me a bunch of time responding to that. Last edited by kei-clone on Mon Aug 14, 2006 10:08 pm; edited 1 time in total |
||||||||
TNaran
Posts: 17 Location: Canada |
|
|||||||
Prove it. Pokemon showed up in 1998, but by then anime was on the growth curve by this point due in large part to Blockbuster suddenly stocking more anime. Pokemon was and is looked down upon by the mainstream. In fact, I liked this summary on wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anime#Popularity_in_the_United_States: “The support for anime among American anime fans is very strong. The availability of anime in America is truly impressive, especially within the anime fan community. Awareness of Japanese animation in America is at an all time high. However, mainstream acceptance of anime in America lags far behind the advances anime has made in other respects."
Prove 4Kids did something for the market. I at least attempted to provide some evidence which you simply rejected.
And laugh at it.
You figure Pokemon convinced Cartoon Network to show Cowboy Bebop? |
||||||||
Mozilla
SPAMMER
Posts: 93 |
|
|||||||
I don't expect that day to come anytime soon, they have hundreds of millions stored in the bank. And besides, I wouldn't expect their profit to increase simply because alot of new shows are premiering in the fall, so they were busy producing new episodes. I predict that their next statement will indicate profit.
First of all, there is a HUGE difference between the purpose of an OP (song) in Japan and North America. In Japan, OP's are primarily ment to promote the song, however in North America, its usually there just ..... well, just to get the audience to tune into the show. So by 4Kids "failing" to further OP's, that statement is absolutely ludacris. Besides, the OP shouldn't have to further Anime into mainstream, its the actual storyline and plot that should promote it. |
||||||||
Mozilla
SPAMMER
Posts: 93 |
|
|||||||
I don't expect that day to come anytime soon, they have hundreds of millions stored in the bank. And besides, I wouldn't expect their profit to increase simply because alot of new shows are premiering in the fall, so they were busy producing new episodes. I predict that their next statement will indicate profit.
First of all, there is a HUGE difference between the purpose of an OP (song) in Japan and North America. In Japan, OP's are primarily ment to promote the song, however in North America, its usually there just ..... well, just to get the audience to tune into the show. So by 4Kids "failing" to further OP's, that statement is absolutely ludacris. Besides, the OP shouldn't have to further Anime into mainstream, its the actual storyline and plot that should promote it. |
||||||||
OneHotAlchemist
Posts: 85 |
|
|||||||
You seem to have misunderstood my point. 4kids doesn't give a crap about anyone on this site. Why should I worry about them?
First thing, OP=One Piece. Its the common abbreviation for the series. It does also refer to an OP song, but errrm, that doesn't make much sense in this case. Last edited by OneHotAlchemist on Mon Aug 14, 2006 10:11 pm; edited 1 time in total |
||||||||
Wolverine Princess
Posts: 1100 |
|
|||||||
Quoted for truth. I wouldn't be the anime fan I am today if I hadn't found Ranma 1/2, Orphen, and Tenchi Muyo VHS tapes at Blockbuster. |
||||||||
Amibite
Posts: 196 |
|
|||||||
Of course there were, I pointed that out. But the fact is Pokemon is the biggest contributer to the anime market in America (and a lot of other countries, like France, too). Dragonball Z may have helped anime get a foot in the door; but Pokemon kicked the door down and crashed the party. Without Pokemon anime would be far less mainstream than it is today.
But they have heard of it...
Again, I never said anime didn't exist. But thanks to Pokemon's huge mainstream hit (Pokemon being one of the most popular and successful franchises in the world, let alone Japan) it's now even more mainstream.
One Piece is not the holy father of all anime. One Piece being released uncut in America would do nothing for the anime market. Trying to say One Piece would help make it more mainstream like Pokemon did is laughable. |
||||||||
Pokejedservo
Posts: 12 Location: Hollywood, Fl. |
|
|||||||
While I agree that this isn't a major blow they are not really just fine either...
http://www.retrojunk.com/details_articles/734/ This is my take on 4Kids' business situations and practices. |
||||||||
TNaran
Posts: 17 Location: Canada |
|
|||||||
Correct so far.
How do you figure this? What is it with Pokemon fans that makes them believe that because Pokemon caught their attention it must have been what brought everyone else on board. If anything, the anime boom germinated starting with Transformers and Robotech. Robotech was a big rating success in syndication, a rarity for most syndicated children's programming of the time. Then Akira brought in the college/university aged crowd. It was a campus favorite for movie nights across North America and became the topic of essays on modern Japanese culture by hoity-toity lit-crit types. And most anime commentators point to the establishment of many anime companies shortly after the introduction of Akira to the home video market.
Pokemon lead to Cowboy Bebop? Dragonball Z was being shown in syndication and on cable two years before Pokemon hit. And by the time Pokemon hit, Dragonball was in heavy rotation here in Canada on YTV (airing 3 times a day). A sure sign it was getting ratings. How do you figure Pokemon lead to Dragonball's success when all it was famous for was causing seisures?
This is the most bizarre and ignorant statement I have ever read, and I read rec.arts.anime.misc. Ghost in the Shell was a theatrical release and got two thumbs up from Siskel & Ebert: http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/19960412/REVIEWS/604120302/1023 Akira was a critical hit, and a home video hit: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/style/longterm/movies/videos/akira.htm See the dates on those reviews? When they were released, they were recognized. How old are you, by the ways? I was in University when Akira was released and I was not the otaku you see now. And everyone in the SF clubs were talking about it. And Ghost in the Shell was one of the most popular movie nights for the campus movie night. And this was before my university even had an anime club. This was in 1995. Pokemon aired in North America in 1998. How do you explain this? Pokemon leads to Akira and Ghost in the Shell's stature? Come on! The Pokemon fanatics on this board have some serious issues with reality. They have an inflated opinion of the impact of Pokemon and its perception by the mainstream. |
||||||||
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
||
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group