Forum - View topic

NEWS: Problem Children Novels' Weekly Sales Quadruple After Anime

Tanteikingdomkey wrote:

this is not about sales this is does something exist and the answer is yes it does. there is a better example but I don't feel like searching for it now.

Amazing, characters designed by the same person look somewhat similar. This has clearly never, ever happened before in the entire history of animation character designs. Please, continue your examination of this NEW! AND! EXCITING! Phenomenon.

Quote:

Also I heard gj-bu was a unfunny comedy versus joshiraku or acchi kochi which where hilarious

Unlike you, I've actually watched it.

I have watched episode 1 of it and it was unfunny and boring way to generalize me just because I deferred to general opinion.
and thank you for agreeing with me that what I said was right.

now that I am privileged to be allowed to talk by the almighty fencedude. I will begin writing my 20 page on why just because something repeatedly happens that does not mean that it is a good thing, and how idiotic of an argument that is, and how when one objects to another persons point it should be done in a respectful manner and that you need to argue their point and not just say their example is stupid especially when it is a perception based problem.

I didn't find GJ-bu to be amusing and rather generic which I had the opposite reaction to in acchi kocchi that is my opinion and many others share it, I did not mean to come across as wining about it, I just thought it was odd that it had high sales, same thing with the yuryuri series for me.

maybe I did not make this clear earlier but their is a backlash because of the similar designs, but also that no one can prove something 100% in most cases, however it can be reasonable shown. to the character designs there is in addition to the character designs their is the bird
also fans in general feel like not just the bird but that kyon ayi's studio is trolling them with this show especially after the little busters fiasco, which still has a ton of people but hurt over JC staffs little animation.

Quote:

maybe I did not make this clear earlier but their is a backlash because of the similar designs, but also that no one can prove something 100% in most cases, however it can be reasonable shown. to the character designs there is in addition to the character designs their is the bird also fans in general feel like not just the bird but that kyon ayi's studio is trolling them with this show especially after the little busters fiasco, which still has a ton of people but hurt over JC staffs little animation.

That first link goes to a thread from /a/, which is meaningless because /a/ hates and loves everything. Also who gives a crap about what /a/ thinks? I'm looking for you to establish a backlash among Japanese fans, the ones that actually matter on the subject we're discussing, which is Japanese disc sales.

Second, the bird is not inherently a problem. In fact, I quite like the bird, so you can't hold up Dera's presence as an inherent flaw.

Thirdly, this image is completely idiotic on multiple levels. That you have presented it to me as some sort of actual evidence of a backlash is completely insulting, and demonstrates that you do not understand a single thing about how anime is funded and produced.

And finally, KyoAni and Tamako Market have precisely nothing to do with Little Busters, so bringing that up again reinforces the point made above that you have no idea what you are talking about.

also you said it yourself quite well "KyoAni and Tamako Market have precisely nothing to do with Little Busters" that is the problem for people is that for many they can't just enjoy tamako instead they are hen pecked by the idea that "they chose to do this over LB, K-on, or Haruhi"

Tanteikingdomkey wrote:

also you said it yourself quite well "KyoAni and Tamako Market have precisely nothing to do with Little Busters" that is the problem for people is that for many they can't just enjoy tamako instead they are hen pecked by the idea that "they chose to do this over LB, K-on, or Haruhi"

God, is it 2006 all over again? Seriously. This exact same logic was trotted out at the time, only in that case it was Kanon that was preventing us from having more Haruhi.

Anyway, you have not established anything other than baseless speculation.

kyon ayi caused little busters to suffer so they could go off and make a bird troll us.

that is the logic of the spured fans, try and refute it.

also you said it yourself quite well "KyoAni and Tamako Market have precisely nothing to do with Little Busters" that is the problem for people is that for many they can't just enjoy tamako instead they are hen pecked by the idea that "they chose to do this over LB, K-on, or Haruhi" every time the show does a slight slip up. is it fair no it is not, but when fans fell like they have been ignored by the thing they built up then they start to lash out (or hold back on buying discs, because it is their favorite studio) tamako market might just end up being that unfortunate case of wrong place wrong time, which I personally find sad.

ok slight change. Kyon anyi made the adaptation of little busters suffer.

by kyon ayi refusing to do a superior adaptation of little busters, key was forced to go with JC staff that did a sub par adaptation of LB instead. that is what I mean when I say kyon anyi made LB suffer.

The reason why KA said they wouldn't do LB was because they wanted to do their own stuff (chu2 and tamako) first and would not do it in a reasonable amount of time. many fans feel (not me) that tamko market in particular the bird is actually trolling them

does that make sense now? I am not saying that I agree with this argument nor that the backlash is very large. however this backlash does exist and above is their reasoning and logic.

I never said the backlash was big just that it exist. if you guys feel so strongly it does not exist how about you actually produce some evidence that it doesn't exist. (which you probably can't since it's a devils proof)

also I never claimed to know everything on this topic, nor that I was speaking for all haruhi, K-on, or LB fans. however it is a fact that some (again unknown quantity) of these fans feel this way. I have already said it is impossible for me to read or speak japanese and even if I did pull up something you all would probably try and say that the translation was incorrect or was out of context or something.

I never said the backlash was big just that it exist. if you guys feel so strongly it does not exist how about you actually produce some evidence that it doesn't exist. (which you probably can't since it's a devils proof)

Tanteikingdomkey wrote:

I never said the backlash was big just that it exist. if you guys feel so strongly it does not exist how about you actually produce some evidence that it doesn't exist. (which you probably can't since it's a devils proof)

You are the one making the initial claim that a backlash among the Japanese fans exists. Therefore when this backlash is questioned, the burden of proof is on you to prove it exists. It is not on us to prove that it doesn't exist.