Forum - View topic

The X Button - Natural Resources

Well it's hard to discus this with someone who wants to spin Ripley from Alien from not being an actual strong female, but this strange subservient character just like Samus.

Reminder: you are arguing with the person who said this:

However, some folks here are claiming that a lot of the original Japanese hyper-sexualization was lost in translation, and that Americans just don't understand how she was originally intended to be portrayed. I'm not sure how much of that is really true or just hair-splitting, but all I can say is that the character I thought Samus was is a heck of a lot cooler than how I'm seeing her portrayed recently in Japan (Other M comes to mind) and being led to believe here by some commenters.

Zac wrote:

Reminder: you are arguing with the person who said this:

Uh, you're taking statements out of context and trying to spin them for your agenda.

Because people always forget Ripley didn't become the poster child for gun-slinging female action movie heroines until the sequel movie seven years later. It's like how people often ignore the more subdued 'First Blood' set in a small podunk town and go straight for the set-in-Nam sequel movie 'Rambo' for the Rambo franchise.

She was always an independent person, she never cowed to voice her opinion and never comprised it, even when everyone else disagreed with her.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=quR5-FEaM9c

Because "legendary badass" is about as shallow of a description as you can get. That isn't even close to how I describe truly great characters like The Man With No Name, Bruce Wayne, Shinji Ikari, Aya Brea, Lenneth Valkyrie, Lupin III, Revy, Himura Kenshin, Kanji Tatsumi, Fei Fong Wong, Ashley Riot, James Sunderland, Denam Mowne, Aigis, etc. In fact, I actually tend to focus on their more negative qualities first.

It's a description that isn't made for HER benefit but for the player's. It's made to stroke your ego because, like most silent protagonists, the player is meant to project onto her in the name of that ever-so-meaningless term "immersion." Blank slates aren't characters and no amount of out-of-game decriptors is going to remedy that. She doesn't make any actions of her own accord 99% of the time because she lacks free will. The actions of the player and the character are not one and the same. Never will be.

I can name, at best, a handful of instances where Samus expressed herself outside of Fusion and Other M:

Super Metroid: Exposition dump at the beginning. Flashback where she hesitate to shoot the Baby

Metroid Prime 3: Clenches her fist, shoots at Dark Samus when she's absorbing Ghor, moves back when she sees Gandrayda transform into Samus during her death animation.

That's it. That is literally all I ever saw. I cannot guess a personality on that. Samus had a history, but no character. She was blank slate, meant as an escapist avatar for the player. She might as well have been a statue. And no amount of WANTING her to have a personality will ever change that she never had one in the first place.

It kinda sucks people are so hard on a woman going through PTSD.

Well, I'd just like to ask the same question: Why are the high-heels necessary? What do they add to the character? what purpose do they serve?

And now this spin happened, the "actually you guys are down on women" spin.

Also, people have problems with that scene because it makes no real sense for her to have that reaction.