Forum - View topic

NEWS: New Gundam Seed, Gundam Seed Destiny English Dub Reveals More Cast

Compared to characters like Quess/Hathaway or the three orphans from the first Gundam not even remotely close

Given the cast would look drastically different if he actually followed through on those threats? can't hold that against him.

Soldiers who were apart of organization that wasn't above threatening or killing civilians for personal gain.

Was it intentional like Char trying to drop a asteroid on the earth?

Some kids in another Gundam are irrelevant, she's one of the most hated characters I've seen. Like it or not.

Its a big cast so a few could've died in a war epic,

It was a pilot trainee dormitory. They were training to pilot and fight with honor rather than use Mobile Dolls which Treize was against, until Romefeller Foundation took over forcing the use of dishonorable Mobile Dolls which is why Treize stepped down as leader of Oz.
After killing trainee's in their sleep and insulting Noin for being a weak soldier because she's a women Wufei yells at wolves about how weak the enemy was. lol He is more of a clown than Trowa.

Char was not a hero trying to save Earth. He was always against the Earth & its federation, his father is Zeon after all. Fighting for space independence and that all of humankind should migrate to space.

I'll give you that. Although I compare them more towards insane chickens with their heads cut off.

I don't tend to take too much stock in what characters fans hate or like in the gundam series particularly with the hate aspect.

Well yeah if Wing were written like the Gundam series that preceded it and some of the ones that succeeded it, but given how the "Kill Em All" trope is a good part of the reason people didn't like Victory or Iron Blooded Orphan's 2nd season?

Be that as it may doesn't change the reality of the more shady stuff Oz and it's offshoots were willing to do to accomplish it's goals.

Be that as it may it's a bit hard to truly reconcile Char going from being a pragmatic soldier on a quest for revenge against the upper echelons of Zeon, (to being what he was in Zeta which I haven't watched), to becoming a well intentioned extremist whose willing to commit genocide while turning the earth into a inhospitable husk all in the name of some fanciful dream.

There almost always has to he that one character in Gundam that loses their sh!t and does
(or attempts) to do something messed up.

Levonr wrote:

Its a big cast so a few could've died in a war epic,

Well yeah if Wing were written like the Gundam series that preceded it and some of the ones that succeeded it, but given how the "Kill Em All" trope is a good part of the reason people didn't like Victory or Iron Blooded Orphan's 2nd season?

Levonr wrote:

Char was not a hero trying to save Earth. He was always against the Earth & its federation, his father is Zeon after all. Fighting for space independence and that all of humankind should migrate to space.

Be that as it may it's a bit hard to truly reconcile Char going from being a pragmatic soldier on a quest for revenge against the upper echelons of Zeon, (to being what he was in Zeta which I haven't watched), to becoming a well intentioned extremist whose willing to commit genocide while turning the earth into a inhospitable husk all in the name of some fanciful dream.

It matters because were talking about Relena being unlikable or not and fans have spoken strongly about their hate for her.

I said "a few" could've died since it was about war. But these characters were like immortals where even when they try blow themselves up they live. lol

Doesn't change the fact Wufei is a hypocrite for talking about honor yet being
despicable.

He avenged his father, followed by going through with his father's ideology. Its not hard to understand. We were talking about Quatre which has nothing to do with Char Aznable.

Yeah "one character" or a few, for Wing its most of the cast.