Forum - View topic

Preliminary thoughts on SJUSA Bakuman preview

Mushi-Man, that's not the point. I wouldn't mind if they were just weak characters, or uninteresting characters, but the author seems to make the point that all women ruin men's lives and are annyoing, unless they are completely subservient, agreeabale, and perfect porcelain dolls. I find it rather odd. The weirdest portrayal was Takagi's mom, who was an insane lunatic who wanted her son to study to replace her dad. She was portrayed with a warped expression with tears and snot streaming down her face. It just seemed really, really wierd to me. I know Japan has different views about gender, but this is taken to an almost uncomfortable level to me. I'm still enjoying Bakuman better than Deathnote, though.

And there are tons of strong female characters in Shonen titles.
Arale from Dr. Slump, Anna from Shaman King, Kagura from GinTama, Biscuit Kruger from Hunter x Hunter, several characters in Bleach, Claymore, Rosario to Vampire, etc. That hasn't stopped any of the series from gaining popularity. Even in Dragonball- where would Goku be without Bulma?

And these sexist themes are very common in manga such as this. Women in shonen manga tend to either be weak, subservient, annoying, or pointless in most cases. It's only exemplified in this series because of the over use of cliches for women in manga. I'm not saying that it's impossible that they are sexist, just that this is not the conclusion that I jump to when I look at the bigger picture. I see it more as them having realized that young boys tend to like this idea of women more (at least for the time being) and the manga industry tends to support this marketing plan.

For all I know you guys are right and Obata and Ohba are sexist pigs.

Non of Bakuman really comes off as being sexist unless you want to claim that about half of the anime and manga out there is just as (if not more so) prejudice.

I imagine these supposed sexist themes come about in a way that's more like "This is how allot of shonen manga portray women. Lets give it a try, it will probably be successful that way."

But at least half of the anime and manga out there are blatantly sexist.
Japan is enormously backward in terms of its gender politics (cultural relativism be damned...) and that obviously spills over into Japanese media, including manga.
...
This is the bit I don't understand. Why somebody produces media a certain way doesn't have any bearing on whether it is or isn't sexist.
If an artist creates sexist art because everyone else is doing it, or because it's marketable, or because their editor tells them to, that doesn't make the work any less sexist, even if the artist doesn't personally hold those beliefs.

I've been wanting to ask others who read this manga, how truthful is Bakuman's portrayal of the inner workings of Shonen Jump? Does anyone know enough about how shonen jump works to confirm the ideas laid out in the manga?