Reviewby Mike Crandol,
Ruroni Kenshin second OAV series
Seisouhen, part 1
The bulk of the first part of "Seisouhen” is comprised of scenes from the first two seasons of "Rurouni Kenshin", re-imagined in the more realistic style of the first OVA series. As in the previous OVA the animation is of much higher quality than it's TV counterpart, in places rivaling the work of Disney. Unfortunately it's a waste of a great opportunity: instead of redoing the numerous action-packed battles that were "Rurouni Kenshin's" hallmark, the creators have chosen to revisit the quiet, more romantic sequences between Kenshin and Kaoru. Not that there's anything wrong with romance, but the exquisite animation is put to waste as the characters sit still and talk to one another in scenes we've already seen before. The one fight that has been completely redone is Kenshin vs. Jinei, and as expected it is a beautifully animated scene that far surpasses the original version. Swords clash in a fully-animated fury that even exceeds the gorgeous fight between Kenshin and the Shinsengumi that capped off the first OVA series. One waits in vain to see some of Kenshin's other famous battles so gloriously brought to life.....instead we are only treated to very brief shots of Kenshin defeating Sojiro and Shishio.
To make matters worse, the sequences that are presented do not form a cohesive narrative. Only a die-hard Kenshin fan will be able to understand the disjointed snippets of story that make up this new OVA. Even American fans may be confused by the ending sequences, which begin to bring bits of the manga's celebrated Revenge Arc to animation. People in the know may rejoice to finally see the adult Enichi in anime form, but someone unfamiliar with the untranslated Kenshin comics may wonder just who the heck the white-haired guy is.
There are also several inconsistencies of character. The story opens roughly fifteen years after the events of the TV series. Kenshin has left home at the request of Lord Yamagata to fight in defense of Japan "on the continent". Within the historical context of "Rurouni Kenshin", this is probably in reference to the Sino-Japanese War. This was a highly political conflict between China and Japan in which Japan was the aggressor... It is doubtful the peace-loving, idealistic Kenshin would have gotten involved. We also see Kenshin's son, Kenji, with Seijuro Hiko, presumably learning the ways of Hiten Mitsurugi. In an early episode of the TV series Kenshin once remarked, "I do not intend to pass on my skills," the Hiten Mitsurugi Style being far too dangerous for the reformed manslayer to share. He very likely wouldn't want his own son to study such a deadly art. More plausibly, he might have wanted Kenji to learn the non-lethal Kamiya Kasshin fighting style from his mother.
As afore mentioned, the artwork is one of the few strengths of the new Kenshin OVA, but even that has it weak points. The television cast has been overhauled to match the style of the first OVA, which had a decidedly more realistic look. This metamorphosis had previously worked well for Kenshin himself, but the rest of the redesigns prove to be a mixed bag. Yahiko fares pretty well, as does Megumi and Jinei...and an all-to-brief glimpse of the Meiji-era Saito Hajime is truly menacing. The new Sanosuke, however, looks pretty awkward, his original design perhaps being too cartoonish to translate well into this new style. But it is Kaoru's overhaul that is the least successful, which is unfortunate because she is the true main character of this new "Kenshin" anime. It would seem the creators tried too hard to make her look like Tomoe from the previous OVA, and in doing so lost Kaoru's distinctive girlish charm.
"Seisouhen's" music is the one area in which the anime completely excels. Composed in the alternately wistful and intense style of the first OVA series, the score continues to give the "Rurouni Kenshin" OVAs a grand theatrical quality. The closing theme is a gentle piano version of the bouncy, upbeat theme song from the second season of the TV show, which surprisingly enough works really well. It is a shame that little else borrowed from the television series translated successfully to this new work.
Based on the popularity of "Samurai X", ADV Films provided funding for this new series, and it is doubtful it would have been made without their involvement. But many U.S. fans of "Samurai X" have never seen "Rurouni Kenshin", and the first OVA series owes much of it's success in America to it's self-contained story that requires no previous knowledge of the television or manga incarnation. "Seisouhen", on the other hand, is completely incomprehensible to someone who isn't familiar with the first 60-or-so episodes of the TV show. Even a knowledge of later events which transpired only in the manga (which has never been released domestically) is needed to fully understand the story presented in this new OVA. When ADV finally releases it, they can expect a lot of confused and disappointed fans.
Overall (sub) : D+
Animation : A+
Art : C-
Music : A+
+ Technically, some of the best animation to ever come out of Japan, rivals the American masters in terms of motion; musical score to match
Full encyclopedia details about