Forum - View topic

Is anime politically and socially liberal?

After watching couple of anime and reading synopsis of several anime in Wikipedia, I beginning to think that anime is usually politically and socially left-leaning (as well being less politically correct) than U.S. cartoons and other forms of enterntainment.

Well it does makes sense, Japan happens to be more politically and socially liberal than the United States.

Dark Paladin X wrote:

After watching couple of anime and reading synopsis of several anime in Wikipedia, I beginning to think that anime is usually politically and socially left-leaning (as well being less politically correct) than U.S. cartoons and other forms of enterntainment.

That is because you haven't watched enough of manga and adapted anime from him, him, him, and him.

Jeez what point are you trying to make here? I've watched Elfen Lied and it gives a clear message that torture is bad in all forms. Ok, you just showed me four guys here, are you trying to say the anime they make have a right-wing POV?

At least learn some world histories and get informed on current events, before you embarrass yourself once again because you just wanted to voice your opinion. When there are at least four Japanese manga artists did a much better jobs than you did, and this guy alone did so with an all-male private high school full of manly men. So show some respect if you got any.

Ok, so the Japanese may consider themselves to be "conservative" in their POV, but they are politically and socially liberal in western standards.

Therefore unlike yourself with your limited understandings and your bias opinions about the Japanese society and international political view points. Those Japanese manga artists each has more understandings and insights about their Japanese society and different world's view points, than your narrow mindedness can even hope to achieve.

At least learn some world histories and get informed on current events, before you embarrass yourself once again because you just wanted to voice your opinion. When there are at least four Japanese manga artists did a much better jobs than you did, and this guy alone did so with an all-male private high school full of manly men. So show some respect if you got any.

But perhaps comparing Western and Japanese animation is not a good indicator of how accepted those subjects actually are in real life.

Japan seems to feel it is more healthy to explore these subjects early on so they will usually establish a firm experience with them later on.

I think that is something that is thoroughly evident in many anime, and the reason why creative expression by the Japanese exists in ANY medium regardless of its target audience.

This is the most laughable comment I've seen on the forum this month. Japan is sexually more liberal because its society was not bound by biblical monogamy relationship until the introduction of such idea into their laws in 20th century. Other aspects of the Japanese society -- foreign relationships, racism, and social hierarchies in particular -- are notoriously conservative.

dormcat wrote:

This is the most laughable comment I've seen on the forum this month. Japan is sexually more liberal because its society was not bound by biblical monogamy relationship until the introduction of such idea into their laws in 20th century. Other aspects of the Japanese society -- foreign relationships, racism, and social hierarchies in particular -- are notoriously conservative.

That's a very fair observation. On a positive note, almost every Tales of game by Namco-Banda has anti-racism themes.

Is anime politically and socially liberal?

then I replied stating he should look into the political and social views of the otaku community, who are just as liberal as the Berkeley students from my knowledge.

Jeez what point are you trying to make here?

... and reading synopsis of several anime in Wikipedia...

...claiming that the anime promotes child pedophilia and is pornography...

...decide to distribute and dub Elfen Lied and Higurashi no Naku Koro ni without massive censorship...

Japan happens to be more politically and socially liberal than the United States.

Anime is quite liberal on portraying sex and violence.

Not to mention, Japan is more tolerant to alternate forms of sexuality like gayness, lesbianism, etc.

Also, many Americans kinda still have the "cartoons are for children" mindset

but the Japanese have a VERY different view when it comes to cartoons.

I replied stating he should look into the political and social views of the otaku community, who are just as liberal as the Berkeley students from my knowledge.

Take Kodomo No Jikan for example, a story about a 10-year-old schoolgirl developing a love interest with her 23-year-old male teacher. Well, something like this would be tolerated for distribution and broadcast in Japan. But when you try to distribute this anime in United States, you get angry protest from conservative and highly religious right-wing watchdogs, claiming that the anime promotes child pedophilia and is pornography (even though the series is meant to be taken as a COMEDY. Not to mention, there are [url=Vili Fualaau]real life instances where[/url] a student and teacher fall in love with each other and even marry). Because of Kodomo No Jikan will never be English-dubbed forever.

And don't get me started with yaoi and yuri, these are rarely distributed in the U.S. since some people consider it to be porn even though there are non-pornographic ones.

Then, there are scenarios where distributors flips the bird on the watchdog groups and decide to distribute and dub Elfen Lied and Higurashi no Naku Koro ni without massive censorship (both series are very violent and bloody, something that the right-wing watchdogs would protest on). But most of the time, the distributors would kowtow to the watchdogs.

Well it does makes sense, Japan happens to be more politically and socially liberal than the United States. Anime is quite liberal on portraying sex and violence. Not to mention, Japan is more tolerant to alternate forms of sexuality like gayness, lesbianism, etc. Also, many Americans kinda still have the "cartoons are for children" mindset, but the Japanese have a VERY different view when it comes to cartoons.

I made this thread because I made a post in one of Steven Crowder's Youtube videos who was looking into political and social the Berkeley students in California (going under the name Dpaladinx), then I replied stating he should look into the political and social views of the otaku community, who are just as liberal as the Berkeley students from my knowledge.

On the side note, I should make online petitions of getting Kodomo No Jikan and To Aru Majutsu no Index english dubbed and distributed in the United States by A.D. Vision and Disney respectfully (I chose Disney for To Aru Majutsu no Index because Disney beautifully did a nice job distributing and dubbing Miyazaki's anime films and not screwing them over). UPDATE: Nevermind one the petitions, I did create one, but I think most of you would find it as a joke.

After watching couple of anime and reading synopsis of several anime in Wikipedia, I beginning to think that anime is usually politically and socially left-leaning (as well being less politically correct) than U.S. cartoons and other forms of enterntainment.