I've been looking into this show recently and I'm not sure what to make of it... a Pinocchioesque tale according to one review that was in the vein of Lain? I'm not sure I'm too sold on the concept... and frankly after reading a summary of what happens in the first episode it sounds fairly stereotypical...robot girl fighting against mysterious organization, etc. However lots of reviewers have given it critical acclaim. Does it transcend that somewhat kooky/cliche sounding premise? - Thanks
Joined: 03 Nov 2003
Posts: 19136
Location: Indianapolis, IN (formerly Mimiho Valley)
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 6:14 am
Although its initial set-up may remind one of Pinocchio, Key the Metal Idol is one of the most wholly original anime series you'll ever see. Nothing I've seen before or since resembles it much. It does use some traditional Japanese elements which commonly pop up in anime (knowing what a miko is will help in appreciating the series, and it has some scathing things to say about the way the Japanese entertainment industry chews up and spits out idol singers), but it also avoids the cutesiness so pervasive in anime. It tells a completely serious and highly involving story which features strongly-defined characters, one of the best of all anime villains in the thoroughly deplorable Jinsaku Ajo, and one of the more unusual series climaxes you'll ever see. It also leaves in doubt until the next-to-last episode whether or not Tokiko "Key" Mima is really a robot who wishes to become a girl or a seriously messed-up girl who believes she's a robot. Either way, her seemingly-improbable desire to become an idol singer despite her robotic nature is where the series' title comes from.
On the technical side, the artistry is unlikely to impress and does show its age (the series dates to 1994), but at times there are some subtle changes to Key's appearance that are both intentional and very important to the plot. You'll have to watch very closely to catch them, as some are very brief. It features a superb soundtrack loaded with lots of great '90s adult contemporary and pop-rock songs as well as the wonderful series theme "Lullaby;" all the songs are sung in English for the dubbed version. I thought the English dub was quite well-done, but opinions may vary on that. The episode structure is a little weird, as it has 13 regular-length episodes followed up by 90-minute episodes 14 and 15 - and you need to see the latter two to get the whole story. Fortunately they're all normally available on only 3 DVDs, so it's a highly cost-effective series. And do make sure you watch completely through the closing credits on the final episode, as there are bonus homages in the credits and a bonus scene at the end.
Key the Metal Idol is one of my all-time favorite series (as you can probably guess by my avatar and ID). I highly recommend it for anyone who's looking for a serious drama more than a bit off the well-trodden anime path.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Dara-san of Reiwa feels like two manga stitched together, not unlike its monstrous central character.― How should readers approach Dara-san of Reiwa, a story that feels like two manga stitched together, not unlike its monstrous central character? Creator Haruomi Tomotsuka shared at the end of volume one that the story originated as a web manga and was, at least at first, an outlet for his own fetish...
Akane-banashi finally has its turn in the weekly limelight, and Needy Girl Overdose catches up in the cumulative chart thanks to steady high marks since week 3. Check out our weekly user rankings!― Let's have a look at what ANN readers consider the best (and worst) of the season,
based on the polls you can find in our Daily Streaming Reviews
and on the Your Score page with the latest simulcasts. Ke...
When a manga has a two-page disclaimer, you know you're in for a good time.― When a manga has a two-page disclaimer, you know you're in for a good time. And let me tell you, Reform with No Wasted Draws - The Legend of Koizumi's first volume is a hell of a ride. My initial thought was, “Why bother with using real people?” but after reading this volume, I've come to understand why it was a much more e...
It's a smorgasbord of new announcements from a variety of showcases! Jean-Karlo's got the details from the Japanese side of gaming.― Welcome back, folks! I took up the challenge of playing Kirby: Return to Dream Land Deluxe over the weekend. It is as charming as you'd expect. Also deeper than I expected. I'm used to the Copy abilities in a Kirby game having varied move lists; they've done that since...
It's easy to miss a true seasonal anime highlight, but you'll regret leaving the beautiful Nippon Sangoku on your "watch later" list.― With more anime than ever to choose from and high-profile series split among several streaming services, it's easy to miss a true seasonal highlight. Nippon Sangoku The Three Nations of the Crimson Sun first caught my attention while preparing for the Spring 2026 Ani...
Kasagi Labo has overseas plans for film of indie music video― Illustrator Akiwashi and Euluca Lab's self-produced music video "Living in a World Without Magic" ("Mahō no Nai Sekai de Ikiru to Iu Koto" or Mahoseka for short) has an animated feature-length film project in the works. The original music video is below: Akiwashi served as the director, scriptwriter, character designer, animator, backgrou...
Creator of Yawara, Master Keaton, 20th Century Boys, Pluto, Billy Bat starts Saigo no Manga Kyōshitsu― The July issue of Shogakukan's Big Comic Original Special (Big Comic Original Zōkan) magazine announced on Friday that Naoki Urasawa will launch the new manga series Saigo no Manga Kyōshitsu (The Final Manga Classroom) in the September issue on August 12. The announcement teased, "What's Urasawa tr...
Traces of Gintama's heart and hilarity are definitely here, but each episode goes on five minutes too long in service of a tacked-on climax.― Gintama is one of the most celebrated comedy manga of all time. Hideaki Sorachi smashing aliens into the tail-end of the Sengoku era was every bit as bold as when Akira Toriyama dropped dinosaurs and mechs (and eventually aliens) into Journey to the West. What...
Creator Coco Uzuki drew commemorative illustrations for anime debuting in 2027― A new official X/Twitter account opened on Friday to announce that Coco Uzuki's Fall in Love, You False Angels (Koiseyo Mayakashi Tenshi-domo) manga is getting a television anime in 2027. Uzuki shared illustration to commemorate the announcement: The official X/Twitter account for the Kashiwa branch of the Cybex cafe cha...
Manga last published chapter in March 2023― The July issue of Shogakukan's Gessan (Gekkan Shōnen Sunday) magazine revealed on Friday that Ayumi Ishii's historical manga Nobunaga Concerto will resume in the magazine's next issue on July 10, and will also end in three chapters. This will be the first new chapter for the manga since March 2023.The manga's 22nd compiled book volume shipped in February 2...
Coop and Chris explore anime film reimaginings of series and the madness of trying to find a copy.― Coop and Chris explore anime film reimaginings of series and the madness of trying to find a copy. Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by the participants in this chatlog are not the views of Anime News Network. RetroCrush streams Adolescence of Utena and Aim for the Ace! Pluto streams Space...
Stranger Than Heaven's combat requires a more methodical approach. You can't just spam a button or two continuously like you could in the brawler-centric Yakuza games.― Despite not having the title “Yakuza” or “Like a Dragon” in its title, Stranger Than Heaven takes place in the same universe as those games. It's actually a prequel, detailing the origins of the Tojo Clan, which is prominently featur...
This noble’s vacation might be gentle on the eyes and ears, but recommending it is another story.― A Gentle Noble's Vacation Recommendation centers around a young duke, Lizel, who is magically transported into a kingdom he does not recognize. He gets by through becoming an adventurer, hiring a bodyguard, Gil, and together they wander the kingdom as part of a vacation where serendipity holds the rein...
Resident Evil Veronica producer Yoshiaki Hirabayashi talked about the challenges of creating remakes, the decision to change the original's title, and what the team would add.― At Summer Game Fest 2026, Anime News Network got a chance to sit down in a group Q&A with Resident Evil Veronica producer Yoshiaki Hirabayashi to discuss the challenges of creating remakes, the decision to change the original...
Yūto Uemura stars in anime from HOTLINE studio― A website opened on Wednesday to announce the television anime adaptation of writer Izushiro and illustrator Ruria Miyuki's The Greatest Magicmaster's Retirement Plan (Saikyō Mahōshi no Inton Keikaku) light novel series. The website revealed the anime's teaser promotional video, teaser visual, lead cast member, staff, and 2027 premiere. Miyuki and Karu...