Forum - View topic

NEWS: Madoka Magica -Walpurgisnacht: Rising- Anime Film's Full Trailer Unveils FictionJunction

I think it was a mistake to try to continue this series beyond the TV/second film's magnificent ending. I saw Rebellion once when it first came out; ever since, it has been one of those sequels like "Alien 3" and "The Last Jedi", that I simply refuse to acknowledge. What this new film will need to do in order to change my mind is pull off a finale that is so good that it justifies having undone the original ending. I don't think they can do that.

"having undone the original ending"
I get why people came to this conclusion when it first came out. I was under the same impression then, when it wasn't on disc yet and I only had one theater viewing to parse what happened in the ending. In the years since, though, it's rare to find anyone who thinks this is what happened. Rebellion went to some pretty extensive lengths to make it clear that Madoka's wish is still active and the Law of Cycles (Ultimate Madoka) is still out there doing her thing. The main difference is that the human Madoka is on earth and Homura is pulling strings to make sure that witches can't exist in this specific world (that Ultimate Madoka is locked out of) either, and that curses don't overwhelm humanity. The new trailer even hints at how she might be doing this.

Rebellion was a character study of Homura, but it also was a critique of Madoka's wish. Specifically, a 14-year-old girl working to save all magical girls across history is a huge undertaking. She succeeds in giving hope, but happiness... is another thing. You need people you care about to help you. I'm of the personal opinion that the new movie is going to focus on both Madoka and Homura's mutual self-sacrificial nature and lack of self-worth. Madoka wasn't wrong to make her wish, but she was wrong to hurt herself to make it come true. Homura wasn't wrong to want Madoka's happiness, but now she's putting a massive burden on herself to hold together her new world and you can tell she's not happy herself. This new movie might put them both in a position where they become partners to fulfill both their wishes, and relieve the heaviest burdens from each other. They're both worth saving and deserve happiness, and Rebellion created Akuma Homura so she may do exactly that as Madoka's equal. That's my hope, at least. Obviously, the ending of the new movie could be another crazy twist (headache if so), but Rebellion's twist ending didn't contradict the message in its main conclusion, and if they do it again, WR doesn't have to contradict the movie's thematic conclusion either.

What Homura did at the end was truly evil, lets not forget what happened to the other magical girls, especially Sayaka. Her new world, is falling apart at the seams. Personally, I believe the writers broke Homura's character for the plot.

In the show Homura creates a cycle that causes others to suffer because she's unable to accept Madoka's self-sacrificial nature in saving the world from Walpurgisnacht at the cost of her life, in Rebellion Homura creates a cycle that causes others to suffer because she's unable to accept Madoka's self-sacrificial nature in becoming Madokami. How you take these two things to be disparate and the latter a sign of "breaking" a character, I would love to hear

Homura created a cycle of trying a whole bunch of different tactics because Walpurgisnacht kept winning. Through these many cycles, Madoka didn't have the power to save the world any more than the rest of them did. It was only through the repetition of that cycle that the energy surrounding Madoka was increased to the level that allowed her to finally make that wish and have it granted.

This is one of those agree to disagree things. It has been argued 'ad infinitum' here in the forums anytime Madoka Magica Rebellion is brought up. At this time, no amount of discussion will cause anyone to change their mind at this late date.