Forum - View topicSentenced to be a Hero (TV) (w/ index).
|
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Next |
| Author | Message | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Edjwald
 Posts: 3507 |
|
||
Season 01: Sentenced to be a Hero (TV) Season 02: Sentenced to be a Hero (TV 2) Source: Light Novel (ongoing @ 8 volumes, written by Rocket Shokai, illustrated by Mephisto) Demographic: Seinen Animation Studio: Studio Kai Genres: action, adventure, drama, fantasy, mystery, psychological, supernatural, thriller Themes: aristocracy, betrayal, chases, conspiracy, crime, dark fantasy, demons, dragons, explosions, factions, goddesses, gore, idealism, knights, medieval, military, monsters, religious sect, resurrection, revenge, social stigma, sorcery, superpowers, transformations, trauma, war Plot Summary: Heroism—a punishment for only the worst criminals. Those sentenced to the fate of a hero are forced to fight at the front lines against the demon king's army—and if they die, they can expect to be revived and continue the battle. But when their leader, convicted of killing a goddess, meets another goddess himself, the contract they forge may be enough to change the world... Air Date & Platform: Season 01: Episode 01: January 03, 2026 (Saturday), Episode 02+: January 15, 2026 (Thursday) Available on: Crunchyroll Season 02: Pending Available on: Pending Episode Count / Runtime: Season 01: 12 episodes Season 02: Pending Total: 12 episodes ---------------------------------- EPISODE INDEX (Clicking on the episode will [eventually] take you to Tony K.'s post that has a summary, comments, and screen-caps) Episode 01: Sentence: Support Retreat From Couveunge Forest Episode 02: Sentence: Clear the Zewan Gan Tunnels (Part 1) Episode 03: Sentence: Clear the Zewan Gan Tunnels (Part 2) Episode 04: Episode 04: Standby Order: Mureed Fortress Episode 05: Sentence: Defense Against Corruption at Mureed Fortress (Part 1) Episode 06: [url=]Sentence: Defense Against Corruption at Mureed Fortress (Part 2)[/url] Episode 07: [url=]Sentence: Feigned Day Off at Port City Ioff[/url] Episode 08: [url=]Sentence: Undercover Investigation in District of Sodrick (Part 1)[/url] Episode 09: [url=]Sentence: Undercover Investigation in District of Sodrick (Part 2)[/url] Episode 10: [url=]Sentence: Aid in Evacuation of Ioff Cheg Port (Part 1)[/url] Episode 11: [url=]Sentence: Aid in Evacuation of Ioff Cheg Port (Part 2)[/url] Episode 12: [url=]Sentence: Aid in Evacuation of Ioff Cheg Port (Part 3)[/url] OP1: ED1: [EDIT: Fancy opener stuff edited and index added. -TK] |
|||
|
|||
|
Harleyquin
Posts: 3443 |
|
||
|
#1-#2
This season is ridiculously stacked with blockbuster adaptations, and this is one of those that has been heavily hyped. It starts off as a double-header as well, and the animators certainly know how to grab the attention of the casual viewer. It's not the most original plot, but the mix of vengeance, conspiracy and over-the-top action set pieces never fails to provide entertainment. It's quite the start as well. One of the individuals sentenced to an unending cycle of death and reincarnation as the despised cannon fodder ironically labelled as "Yuusha" is desperately running away from monsters also ironically called "Fairies" in a complete inversion of the archetype from most fantasy works. Before he gets horribly eaten despite having run his lungs out to save his life, our anti-hero protagonist intervenes to save the day. And what a protagonist he is. Xylo has one of the worst demeanours of any protagonist in recent seasons, and he hates his current occupation as cannon fodder as well as the knightly orders who push him around yet go off on suicide missions in the name of "honour". Despite all that, he still can't bring himself to walk away and let the knights die dog's deaths, so he does everything he can to save them despite being metaphorically spat at for his efforts. Even his companion Dotta thinks he's completely crazy, despite being a serial thief and pilferer any chance he gets. The rest of the double-header proceeds along with Xylo smashing through hordes of demon king monsters in the flashiest method possible. But before that , the loaded coffin Dotta was trying to make off with turns out to be a sleeping "Goddess" (read: living weapon) who promptly takes a shine to Xylo and is practically begging him to use her for her intended purpose. Xylo for his part seems unusually knowledgable about how the living weapons work, and does his utmost to reject her advances until they are out of options and he has to contract with her to avoid complete annihilation. I've seen this Goddess's powers before, most recently from Fate Stay Night and Gilgamesh/Emiya. Not quite the same, but Xylo ends up using the near infinite arsenal effectively having run out of his usual equipment for flashy explosions. After another over-the-top showdown against one of the numbered demon lords and unexpected assistance from the pilfering Dotta, the pair get the job done practically single-handedly and the death-wish commander promptly threatens Xylo with execution for unauthorized contracts. The last scene puts Xylo's anti-social persona into perspective. Having been set up by the powers that be and lost his previous companion, he's understandbly bitter and jaded about using Goddess powers once more. That quest for revenge is still driving him onwards, and he knows if he's killed he will slowly lose himself and his memories. He won't give up until he gets his vengeance, and it looks like his quest is a long one since the kingdom in charge of this active warzone is full of corrupt self-serving officials willing to sacrifice him and his companions as pawns to maintain their status. At least now with a new contract, he has a fighting chance to achieve his goal even if he's still stuck in the franchise equivalent of Warhammer 40K's penal legions and will likely be sent to another suicide mission to keep him as far away from the conspirators as possible. Plenty to like with the premise and the world-building, although the characters are really unlikeable compared to other franchises. Can't go wrong with the action buffet it serves up if this double-header is any indication. |
|||
|
|||
|
Edjwald
Posts: 3507 |
|
||
|
I'm going to say right off that bat that I like this show and fully expect to watch it to its conclusion. I do think that the hype preceding it is overinflated and might wind up hurting the anime more than helping it, but I could be wrong about that. If I wind up having the same complaints episode after episode but still like the show overall, I'll do what I did with Kaiju #8 season 2 and just watch the show and shut up so I don't spend my time trying to ruin the experience for everyone else. Just to be clear, I do think that Kaiju#8 S2 lost a lot of the charm of season 1 though. Ahem.
I'll start with the two main complaints that had me liking this show instead of loving it, then end on the positive. (1) My main complaint is that the action consists of way too many explosions. It's like watching a series of firecrackers going off for a third of the show. My own personal preferences lean towards grim fantasies that are more grounded. For example, I loved both Goblin Slayer and Grimgar, Fantasy and Ash (I know some people did not) where the action sequences were ruthless, pragmatic, and defined. Here, a lot of the action was, "Yell about effort!" Cue the vaguely operatic music! Explosion, explosion, explosion. (2) My second main complaint is again largely a personal preference. Recently, I have found myself weary of protagonists who spend more than 70% of the time yelling while they go through their edgelord routine. I couldn't make it through more than two episodes of Tougen Anki and Gachiakata, although I fully believe the latter is probably worth seeing and that I'm being a big poophead, and I intend to give it another shot someday. I don't dislike the character of Xylo at all. I just wish he'd take a cue from Clint Eastwood style characters and realize that less is more and shut the #$%& up for awhile, or speak with restrained intensity rather than volume. It's like listening to a neighbor's dog barking all the time. Alright, that's my criticism. Here's why I liked it. (I) When Crunchyroll first streamed the anime on my TV, I got the dubbed version. I passively went along for about 5 minutes and then switched to the subbed version, and this is another example where I think the subbed version is superior. The actors playing Xylo and the goddess did a great job and in some cases added texture and depth where the writing of the dialogue did not. (II) Yeah, I thought the action was too undefined and disorienting, but the...I'm going to call it the dynamic sense of motion just to try to sound intelligent...was effective. And while the music I called vaguely operatic was overused IMHO, it was still leagues above a typical anime. (III) I find the plight of the goddess...and part of that plight is that she doesn't even know she has a plight...pulling some of my rusted heart strings. Our boy Xylo is obviously a tsundere, and I wish he'd be honest with the world and himself and instead of going on and on about hating goddesses, just say that he hates the system that creates them to be used while pretending to worship them. (!V) There's a revenge story in the making, and it seems like a pretty good one. |
|||
|
|||
|
smurky turkey
Posts: 4990 |
|
||
|
That was an effective episode in me now being sure that I will watch until the very end. Part of that is the setting being unique enough to feel fresh: it is welcome to have a different kind of hero for once. That said, despite all his sassy grumblings I fully expect Xylo to save humanity with his new goddess/weapon in the end. I am not sure if humanity deserves it though since most of the characters thus far are indeed not all that pleasant (the church being corrupt is so common in anime that I am not even going to comment on it).
Besides that I like the presentation with great animation and even better music. The hero team seems to contain a lot of quirky characters. |
|||
|
|||
rapata
 Posts: 96 |
|
||
|
The Holy Knights seem to suck at their job. In most of the scenes they were shown to get one-sidedly slaughtered by the demon beasts, and their strategy as presented didn't seem very convincing. Making a big stand to death far away to protect a transport mission, while there are demon beasts behind the lines that anyway slaughter said mission? Long-distance telepathic communication exists, but appears not used? All the while the two heroes manage to not only stay alive but curb-stomp the beasts with truckloads of awesome exploding daggers.
Action itself was OK, but I have questions. Maybe they'll get answered, not really enough information in this ep to explain why the MC is such a hot shot, and why everybody else is a bumbling fool. In any case looks like there may be lots of backstabbing going on in the court/temple and maybe this mess advances someone's agenda. |
|||
|
|||
Yttrbio
 Posts: 3822 |
|
||
|
These characters are such downers. Why is everyone so grumpy all the time? Turn that frown upside down!
"We've run out of ammo!" "Oh the noes!" "Look, the bad guy is doing the thing where if we had ammo, it would totally kill us" "Hey, guys, look at all this ammo I found." "Yay! Fire!" |
|||
|
|||
Tony K.
 SubscriberModerator  Posts: 12058 Location: Frisco, TX |
|
||
|
Original discussion started here.
---------------------------------- Episode 01: Sentence: Support Retreat From Couveunge Forest ---------------------------------- Summary: Xylo, a convicted criminal sentenced as a hero for punishment, saves his fellow hero Dotta and finds a coffin that he stole from the Holy Knights containing a goddess. Upon awakening, the 13th goddess Teoritta asks Xylo to form a pact with her, but he refuses. That night, Venetim informs them that the commander of the Holy Knights' main force, Kivia, has ordered the squad to charge into the Blight. With the source of the Blight, the approaching, Xylo unsuccessfully tries convincing Kivia to retreat. As the knights fall in battle, Teoritta convinces Xylo to form a pact. ---------------------------------- Comments: Fate/Clevatess Suicide Squad resurrection. I see elements from a lot of different franchises, and I'm liking it. You've got the whole master/servant pact from Fate, the dark fantasy art style of Clevatess, the whole "being a hero is your punishment, but we'll blow your head off, if you don't" from Suicide Squad, and all with one little fantasy caveat of resurrection, which I might even argue is a reference to the Lazarus Pit from Batman, so make that two DC Comics nods. The social stigma theme thrust upon heroism is very interesting. One the one hand, you have the regular Holy Knights that frown on it, because they know the person who was assigned it was bad in the first place. But at the same time, Teoritta is touting how it's such an honor to save people. That being said, I'm very curious how the religious sect views heroism in general. Like, is it an actual virtue and part of the religion's moral code, or have they always deemed it as punishment, because of all the social implications involved? There were also a lot of explosions in this. In the Encyclopedia, the genre "action" has "explosions" listed as a descriptor for a type of action. But explosions, to me, always felt like an after-effect and result of a chase, gunfight, fistfight, etc., and were far and few between. But holy moly, there were a lot of explosions in this. A lot of the trivia sections for IMdB movie entries will have a body count for action movies. I think it's safe to say the explosion count for this is every blighted demon/monster killed, which was a lot. I should go back and count them. Anyway, I love the world-building, so far. The art and animation are quite slick. Studio Kai doesn't have a whole lot of epic action titles under their belt (the last show they did was rom-com A Star Brighter Than the Sun). But looking at the Encyclopedia credits, they had a whole lot of help for Key Animation from some very reputable studios. If anybody knows how the industry and how that works, I'd like you tell me and how often it happens, 'because this looks awesome. Going from a rom-com to epic action seems like a big jump. And if Studio Kai is getting that much help, is it really their product, so long as a certain percentage is done by them? Also, y'all know how I love revenge stories. So consider me on board for the season. Hopefully, the source material and anime adaptation will finish in our lifetime (unlike poor Berserk). ---------------------------------- Screen Caps:  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
|
|||
|
|||
Blood-
 Bargain Hunter Posts: 25599 |
|
||
|
This was not a show I was initially going to bother to sample but then the buzz attracted my attention. I really am down on most fantasy titles these days having plodded through way too many mediocre and outright bad ones. So I was happy that this didn't turn out to be a bog standard yawnfest. I thought the monster designs and concepts were interesting but I also thought the battle stuff went on for too long. Most of the characters are either jerks or irritating in some way so that's not a plus. But overall more than enough to keep me coming back next episode. Not sure yet this is a keeper, but it has promise as one.
|
|||
|
|||
|
Eilavel
Posts: 477 |
|
||
|
The characters didn't really stand out to me, certainly there weren't any I was attached to. The world is interesting but I wasn't hooked into where the show was going as a whole piece.
For a recent example, Cleavatess quite ably mixed lighter and comedic moments with dark action content, here I really felt like the gears were grinding for me. It was like I was flipping between two worlds. It probably doesn't help the comic relief child like goddess represents a bag of character tropes I can't stand. I also generally find "everyone is really horrible to the super powerful people" a pretty unconvincing trope though at least thats got world building around it here. It certainly has more effort in than most fantasy series, with differentiated world building and designs and some fun action scenes (as well as some less fun ones). Will that be enough for me to stick with it? I'm unsure. |
|||
|
|||
|
Edjwald
Posts: 3507 |
|
||
|
Y'know, as soon as I saw that the action was going to be taking place in a mine, I thought How are they going to explosion explosion explosion without bringing the whole damn thing down on their heads? And then Xylo said the same thing, sort of.
I like the two new additions to the Hero unit alright. Berserker-san works fairly effectively as a living testimony to what being reborn again and again and again and losing a bit of yourself each time could do to a person. I also found myself wondering - if the only way to sever the goddess pact is by mutual consent or death, would Xylo dying count if he was going to be reborn later? Could Xylo be counting on that at the end of the episode? I've heard people complaining about the goddess being annoying as a youngin' and normally I'd be 100 percent on that. But here, it at least makes more sense than usual. If I understand it, these are innocent supernatural beings taken out of a chrysalis and turned into walking, talking warheads. The goddesses are surrounded by people dressing the grim realities of their situation in terms of heroism and sacrifice while shielding the goddesses from the more complex evils of war. In that regard, it makes sense that the goddesses are somewhat childlike. And I did feel empathy for the goddess, who is being exposed to much darker truths than she would have been if she had been handed off by the transfer unit as originally intended. That said, I personally would prefer an adult blank slate or innocent. As to his majesty the hero, I don't know that they milked Nutso-san for as much entertainment value as they could have, but it's a cool concept. I enjoyed the show. And I like that the captain and Xylo are forming a begrudging understanding. |
|||
|
|||
|
Harleyquin
Posts: 3443 |
|
||
|
#2
After the pilot episode, I was wondering what direction the series was going to take after its flashy entrance. The trailer for this week gave me a clue regarding what was to come, and together with the adaptation's full title I have a vague idea of how it's going to go. The penal legion plays the role of scouts and an expendable vanguard used to clear the way for the main army (paladins) to do the real work of completing the military mission objectives. They are executed instantly (and resurrected later) if they disobey orders, but once they've finished the tasks assigned to them they are free to do what they wish, including die dog's deaths since no one cares for expendable criminals. As for the conventional military forces, they come in all stripes. The pilot's suicidally brave commander turns out to be less one-dimensional than she was first portrayed, or perhaps having her life saved by Xylo and his new contracted goddess made her reassess her world view. Perhaps it's a bit of both, since she is visibly shaken by the news several uncorrupted miners are still inside the mine depths and even deems it necessary to ask the former commander of a knight platoon for his tactical assessment of a rescue operation unsanctioned by the top brass. Being a fantasy work, I'm not sure I agree with her choice of footwear, but she's no mug on the battlefield even if she can't hold a candle to the expendables who are nominally hers to command as she sees fit. Teoritta might be childishly annoying, but how many ways can one describe a living weapon that has zero knowledge of how the world works when activated? Going the other extreme would have made her appearance so out of sync with omniscience there wouldn't be much to portray. At any rate, with her being who she is right now Xylo can slowly influence her in ways he might not even be consciously aware of, and if she maintains a sunny disposition despite his stubborn cynicism it would be a minor miracle on par with Xylo not getting killed at least once this quarter. Xylo immediately suspects there's more to this suicide mission than it seems, but he can't do much more except give the finger to all those hoping he gets killed by this arc's horrors and earn even more credit to his name to rub it in. He cares little about the civilians, but at this point he's so fed up nothing less than destroying the source of this mess at source will help him blow off enough steam. Even the top brass aren't stupid enough to kill him while he's doing the work of several paladin platoons on his own for virtually no payment or recognition, and next week's only question is whether he does get backup for his one-man army advance into enemy territory. There are quite a few "Heroes" to be portrayed, and this arc's characters certainly understate Teoritta's statement about the sentenced criminals being a diverse and odd bunch. The berserker has been at it for so long he's little more than a beast and Xylo sees the fate of all Heroes who have been doing the job and dying for so long that they lose everything that makes them human. The deluded "monarch" is a completely different oddball: sentenced for a failed rebellion and clearly delusional he nonetheles retained the skills at crafting holy seals which can be used in a far more versatile manner than Xylo's own pair of strictly murderous tools. There are others featured in the ED, and I look forward to seeing them introduced and seeing what role they play when battle is thrust upon them. |
|||
|
|||
|
Blood-
Bargain Hunter Posts: 25599 |
|
||
|
I really like the visual look of this show. I've already wearied of the "enthusiastic goddess / cranky warrior" dynamic of our two leads, but so be it. More than enough other stuff going on to hold my interest.
|
|||
|
|||
|
smurky turkey
Posts: 4990 |
|
||
|
Given all the shit he has been through and the situation he is in I would say that Xylo is justified in being cranky. I wonder if and how he will get a chance to get back at those who wronged him. Given enough suicide missions he is bound to die plus failing or disobeying an order will get him killed too. Humanity might fall first though since the description about lost land makes it sound like they are losing quite badly. The setting is interesting in that a tank and other objects were shown.
|
|||
|
|||
ACｘS
 Posts: 1226 |
|
||
|
1:
Wow, where the hell did this one come from? I had never heard of this show, nor had I heard any buzz about it before watching. I only stumbled upon it when I learned how highly rated the first episode was. The cinematics and overall production were incredible. The aesthetics can be a mixed bag, which I understand, but it's amazing for what it's worth. Relentless action from the get-go for a first episode that's almost an hour long; that's how you know the show wants to start with a huge bang. The character archetypes are not original: you have the surly main guy, the cowardly yet resourceful sidekick, the stubborn one, and most importantly, the Bratty Half-Pint. Yeah, the motley crew is all here. I would say this is a classic formula, but for the most part, it works, so I'll keep it at that. Now, the story has done enough to keep me interested. During the whole battle, bits and pieces of the background story were revealed, so you could kinda piece them up, but not enough to know the full story yet. That last scene is where they showed their hand: a tale of an unstoppable force, conspiracy, and revenge. Yeah, another classic formula for a story, too. I didn't see this one coming at all. Not a title I was excited for, but man, what a first episode that was. Another show in the bag because it's too exciting. My thoughts on episode 2 soon. P.S. What the hell is up with Winter 2026? Why is this season so fire? |
|||
|
|||
|
ACｘS
Posts: 1226 |
|
||
|
2:
Man, I love this show. The action just doesn't stop. The story just keeps going, and I love it. There are many more Heroes like Xylo, all of which are criminals, so they're quite literally Suicide Squad. The Demon Blight may seem like the villains of the show, but clearly someone up there is plotting something. The fun just keeps coming. And like it or not, the animation is incredible. It's fluid and dynamic, almost to the same level as JJK. Studio KAI is clearly on to something. I looked up its list of productions, and learned that I have never watched any of their works before this. Although, it has produced Uma Musume and I have seen bits and pieces that the visuals are, well, surprisingly extraordinary. Keep it going, please. |
|||
|
|||
 |
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
|
|
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group